Abstract:Environmental hazard assessments for chemicals are carried out to define an environmentally "safe" level at which, theoretically, the chemical will not negatively affect any exposed biota. Despite this common goal, the methodologies in use are very diverse across different countries and jurisdictions. This becomes particularly obvious when international scientists work together on documents with global scope, e.g., in the World Health Organization (WHO) International Program on Chemical Safety. In this article, we present a study that describes the extent of such variability and analyze the reasons that lead to different outcomes in deriving a "safe level" (termed the predicted no effect concentration [PNEC] throughout this article). For this purpose, we chose 5 chemicals to represent well-known substances for which sufficient high-quality aquatic effects data were available: ethylene glycol, trichloroethylene, nonylphenol, hexachlorobenzene, and copper (Cu). From these data, 2 data sets for each chemical were compiled: the full data set, that contained all information from selected peer-review sources, and the base data set, a subsample of the full set simulating limited data. Scientists from the European Union (EU), United States, Canada, Japan, and Australia independently carried out hazard assessments for each of these chemicals using the same data sets. Their reasoning for key study selection, use of assessment factors, or use of probabilistic methods was comprehensively documented. The observed variation in the PNECs for all chemicals was up to 3 orders of magnitude, and this was not simply due to obvious factors such as the size of the data set or the methodology used. Rather, this was due to individual decisions of the assessors within the scope of the methodology used, especially key study selection, acute versus chronic definitions, and size of assessment factors. Awareness of these factors, together with transparency of the decision-making process, would be necessary to minimize confusion and uncertainty related to different hazard assessment outcomes, particularly in international documents. The development of a "guideline on transparency in decision-making" ensuring the decision-making process is science-based, understandable, and transparent, may therefore be a promising way forward.

Derivation of Aquatic Predicted No-Effect Concentration (PNEC) for Ibuprofen and Sulfamethoxazole Based on Various Toxicity Endpoints and the Associated Risks.

Assessing Ecological Risk of Cyanotoxins Based on Interspecies Correlation Estimation and Species Sensitivity Distributions

Pharmaceutical Compounds in Aquatic Environment in China: Locally Screening and Environmental Risk Assessment

Deriving Acute and Chronic Predicted No Effect Concentrations of Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products Based on Species Sensitivity Distributions.

Deriving aquatic PNECs of endocrine disruption effects for PFOS and PFOA by combining species sensitivity weighted distributions and adverse outcome pathway networks

Ecological risk assessment of commonly used antibiotics in aquatic ecosystems along the coast of China

Quinolones Antibiotics in the Baiyangdian Lake, China: Occurrence, Distribution, Predicted No-Effect Concentrations (pnecs) and Ecological Risks by Three Methods.

Predicting environmental risks of pharmaceutical residues by wastewater surveillance: An analysis based on pharmaceutical sales and their excretion data

Component Analysis of a School-Based Substance Use Prevention Program in Spain: Contributions of Problem Solving and Social Skills Training Content

Deriving the predicted no effect concentrations of 35 pesticides by the QSAR-SSD method

Surface proteins of a filarial nematode: a major soluble antigen and a host component on the cuticle of Litomosoides carinii

Ecological Risk Assessment of Amoxicillin, Enrofloxacin, and Neomycin: Are Their Current Levels in the Freshwater Environment Safe?

Tiered ecological risk assessment of nonylphenol and tetrabromobisphenol A in the surface waters of China based on the augmented species sensitivity distribution models

Derivation of predicted no effect concentrations (PNEC) for 2,4,6-trichlorophenol based on Chinese resident species

Derivation of ecological safety thresholds and risk assessment of new SDHI fungicides in farmland system

Derivation of aquatic predicted no-effect concentration and ecological risk assessment for triphenyl phosphate and tris(1,3-dichloro-2-propyl) phosphate

Predicted no effect concentration derivation as a significant source of variability in environmental hazard assessments of chemicals in aquatic systems: An international analysis

Ranking the risks of eighty pharmaceuticals in surface water of a megacity: A multilevel optimization strategy

Quantitative differentiation of toxicity contributions and predicted global risk of fipronil and its transformation products to aquatic invertebrates

Oxidative stress responses in two marine diatoms during sulfamethoxazole exposure and the toxicological evaluation using the IBRv2 index

Comparison of Lesbian and Bisexual Women to Heterosexual Women's Screening Prevalence for Breast, Cervical, and Colorectal Cancer in Missouri.