Abstract:SUMMARY The aerodynamic performance of hovering insects is largely explained by the presence of a stably attached leading edge vortex (LEV) on top of their wings. Although LEVs have been visualized on real, physically modeled, and simulated insects, the physical mechanisms responsible for their stability are poorly understood. To gain fundamental insight into LEV stability on flapping fly wings we expressed the Navier–Stokes equations in a rotating frame of reference attached to the wing's surface. Using these equations we show that LEV dynamics on flapping wings are governed by three terms: angular,centripetal and Coriolis acceleration. Our analysis for hovering conditions shows that angular acceleration is proportional to the inverse of dimensionless stroke amplitude, whereas Coriolis and centripetal acceleration are proportional to the inverse of the Rossby number. Using a dynamically scaled robot model of a flapping fruit fly wing to systematically vary these dimensionless numbers, we determined which of the three accelerations mediate LEV stability. Our force measurements and flow visualizations indicate that the LEV is stabilized by the `quasi-steady' centripetal and Coriolis accelerations that are present at low Rossby number and result from the propeller-like sweep of the wing. In contrast, the unsteady angular acceleration that results from the back and forth motion of a flapping wing does not appear to play a role in the stable attachment of the LEV. Angular acceleration is, however, critical for LEV integrity as we found it can mediate LEV spiral bursting, a high Reynolds number effect. Our analysis and experiments further suggest that the mechanism responsible for LEV stability is not dependent on Reynolds number, at least over the range most relevant for insect flight (100<Re<14,000). LEVs are stable and continue to augment force even when they burst. These and similar findings for propellers and wind turbines at much higher Reynolds numbers suggest that even large flying animals could potentially exploit LEV-based force augmentation during slow hovering flight, take-offs or landing. We calculated the Rossby number from single-wing aspect ratios of over 300 insects, birds, bats, autorotating seeds, and pectoral fins of fish. We found that, on average, wings and fins have a Rossby number close to that of flies (Ro=3). Theoretically,many of these animals should therefore be able to generate a stable LEV, a prediction that is supported by recent findings for several insects, one bat,one bird and one fish. This suggests that force augmentation through stably attached (leading edge) vortices could represent a convergent solution for the generation of high fluid forces over a quite large range in size.

Forewings Match the Formation of Leading-Edge Vortices and Dominate Aerodynamic Force Production in Revolving Insect Wings

The fluid dynamics of flight control by kinematic phase lag variation between two robotic insect wings

Aerodynamic performance of a hovering hawkmoth with flexible wings: a computational approach

A comparative study of the hovering efficiency of flapping and revolving wings

Vortices and Forces in Biological Flight: Insects, Birds, and Bats

Smart wing rotation and ingenious leading edge vortex control modulate the unconventional forces during insects flights

Effect of wingtip-curve on aerodynamic performance in flapping flexible wings: rectangular versus hawkmoth-like

Aerodynamic Modelling of Insect Wings Using Joukowski Transformation

Effect of the Wing Morphology and Structural Form on the Flexible Hovering Flapping Wing

Aerodynamic characteristics of dragonfly in asymmetric flapping

Aerodynamics of a Flapping-Perturbed Revolving Wing

An experimental and three-dimensional computational study on the aerodynamic contribution to the passive pitching motion of flapping wings in hovering flies

Dragonflies Utilize Flapping Wings Phasing and Spanwise Characteristics to Achieve Aerodynamic Performance

Aerodynamics and stability of hawkmoth forward flight with flexible wing hinge

Unsteady Aerodynamic Forces of Tandem Flapping Wings with Different Forewing Kinematics

Modeling and Analysis of a Simple Flexible Wing-Thorax System in Flapping-Wing Insects

Rotational accelerations stabilize leading edge vortices on revolving fly wings

Versatile Reduced-Order Model of Leading-Edge Vortices on Rotary Wings

Aerodynamic Model for Insect Flapping Wings with Induced Flow Effect

Vortices around Dragonfly Wings

Unsteady Aerodynamics and Wing Kinematics Effect in Hovering Insect Flight