Robust detection of clinically relevant features in single-cell RNA profiles of patient-matched fresh and formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) lung cancer tissue

Alexandra Trinks,Miha Milek,Dieter Beule,Julie Kluge,Stefan Florian,Christine Sers,David Horst,Markus Morkel,Philip Bischoff
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13402-024-00922-0
IF: 7.051
2024-02-03
Cellular Oncology
Abstract:Single-cell transcriptional profiling reveals cell heterogeneity and clinically relevant traits in intra-operatively collected patient-derived tissue. So far, single-cell studies have been constrained by the requirement for prospectively collected fresh or cryopreserved tissue. This limitation might be overcome by recent technical developments enabling single-cell analysis of FFPE tissue.
oncology,pathology,cell biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the problem of how to robustly detect clinically relevant features at the single-cell level from fresh tissue, cryopreserved tissue, and formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue. Specifically, the study aims to evaluate the applicability and reliability of FFPE tissue in single-cell transcriptome analysis to overcome the current limitation of single-cell studies mainly relying on prospectively collected fresh or frozen tissue samples. ### Background High-throughput single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) technology has enabled researchers to study cellular heterogeneity within tissues, including human clinical samples. In particular, scRNA-seq is widely used to characterize the complex cellular composition of tumor tissue cohorts and to reveal features that contribute to patient prognosis and treatment resistance. However, single-cell RNA analysis typically requires the prospective collection of fresh tissue samples during surgery or biopsy. Retrospective analysis of frozen or FFPE tissue cohorts would allow for faster correlation of scRNA-seq profiles with clinical features, as many important clinical features (such as tumor genetics, treatment response, and patient survival) can only be obtained weeks to years after sample collection. Additionally, this could unlock archived FFPE tissue collections for single-cell analysis. ### Research Objectives The primary objective of this study is to evaluate the ability of FFPE tissue to detect clinically relevant features at the single-cell level by comparing the single-cell transcriptomes of fresh, frozen, and FFPE tissues. Specific goals include: 1. **Technical Feasibility**: Assess the technical feasibility and data quality of FFPE tissue in single-cell transcriptome analysis. 2. **Biological Consistency**: Verify whether FFPE tissue can retain biological and clinical features similar to those of fresh tissue. 3. **Application Potential**: Explore the potential application of FFPE tissue in the analysis of retrospectively and prospectively collected pathological cohorts, particularly in translational research. ### Methods Researchers obtained fresh, frozen, and FFPE tissue samples from surgical specimens of 3 lung adenocarcinoma patients and conducted single-cell transcriptome analysis. Specific steps included: - **Sample Collection**: Fresh, frozen, and FFPE samples were obtained from the same tissue. - **Sample Processing**: Fresh tissue was enzymatically digested and prepared into cell suspensions; frozen tissue was prepared into nuclear suspensions; FFPE tissue was enzymatically and mechanically dissociated and prepared into nuclear suspensions. - **Library Construction and Sequencing**: Libraries were constructed and sequenced using the 10x Genomics Chromium platform. - **Data Analysis**: Sequence alignment and UMI quantification were performed using Cellranger, and data integration, clustering, and visualization were conducted using Seurat. ### Results - **Data Quality**: Fresh tissue samples had the highest data quality, followed by FFPE tissue samples, with frozen tissue samples having the lowest quality. - **Cell Type Abundance**: FFPE tissue samples had a higher abundance of immune cells and a lower abundance of epithelial and stromal cells. In contrast, fresh tissue samples had a lower abundance of immune cells and a higher abundance of epithelial and stromal cells. - **Cell Feature Heterogeneity**: Despite some technical differences, cell features in FFPE tissue samples were highly correlated with those in fresh tissue samples, especially in terms of pathway activity and biomarker expression. - **Clinical Feature Assessment**: FFPE tissue samples accurately reflected tumor histological grading, expression of the immune evasion marker PD-L1, and biomarkers related to the tumor microenvironment. ### Conclusion The results of this study indicate that FFPE tissue can robustly retain clinically relevant features in single-cell transcriptome analysis, with biological and clinical information similar to that of fresh tissue. This provides new possibilities for the analysis of retrospectively and prospectively collected pathological cohorts, particularly in translational research.