Abstract:Urban heat island effect is one of the prominent phenomena of urban climate. Due to the difference in observation methods and data representativeness,there are many definitions of urban heat island,among them,the canopy layer urban heat island and the surface urban heat island are the most widely used. However,the comparison between the two is relatively rare at present. The "urban effects" refer to the impact of the emergence of cities on the climate of a region. Urban heat island is essentially one of the characteristics of urban effects. There are two commonly used research methods for separating the "urban effects" : "urban-rural difference" and "comparison before and after urbanization",which are calculated from the spatial and temporal differences of observed data respectively. At present,the consistency analysis of the two methods’ conclusions is particularly lacking. Taking Beijing area as the research object,this paper compares and analyzes the values and changes of air temperature and surface temperature, canopy layer heat island and surface heat island in this area by using the ground meteorological station and satellite remote sensing observation data, and further analyzes the comparability of the two methods to separate "urban warming effect". The results show that:（1） The mean values of the five UHI（Urban Heat Island）indicators in Beijing from 2009 to 2017 were as follows:the daytime surface heat island obtained by satellite remote sensing inversion was the largest, followed by the minimum air temperature canopy layer heat island obtained from ground observation and the nighttime surface heat island obtained by satellite remote sensing inversion. The two values were similar.The average temperature canopy layer heat island obtained from ground observation was lower than the former, and the maximum temperature canopy layer heat island obtained from ground observation was much smaller than the other four types.（2） Taking TongZhou station as an example,the results of the two methods of separating "urban warming effect" from 1980 to 2017 were 0.65 ℃/（10a） and 0.61 ℃/（10a）, which were basically consistent. Although there was an underestimation phenomenon in the urban-rural comparison method due to the impact of urbanization on the average temperature of rural stations,the error was within an acceptable range,and the two methods were still mutually substitutable.

Comparing Surface-and Canopy-Layer Urban Heat Islands over Beijing Using MODIS Data

Comparing the diurnal and seasonal variabilities of atmospheric and surface urban heat islands based on the Beijing urban meteorological network

Investigating Diurnal Differences Between Surface and Canopy Heat Islands in Major Provincial Capital Cities of China

Spatiotemporal Patterns of Summer Urban Heat Island in Beijing, China Using an Improved Land Surface Temperature

The Diurnal and Seasonal Characteristics of Urban Heat Island Variation in Beijing City and Surrounding Areas and Impact Factors Based on Remote Sensing Satellite Data

Diurnal and seasonal impacts of urbanization on the urban thermal environment: A case study of Beijing using MODIS data

Modelling spatiotemporal variations of the canopy layer urban heat island in Beijing at the neighbourhood scale

Comparative analysis of different urban heat island indicators and urban effects research methods in Beijing

Simulation of the influence of a fine-scale urban underlying surface on the urban heat island effect in Beijing

Influences of Urbanization on Surface Characteristics As Derived from the Moderate‐Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer: A Case Study for the Beijing Metropolitan Area

Satellite Identification of Atmospheric-Surface-subsurface Urban Heat Islands under Clear Sky

Modelling the Diurnal Variations of Urban Heat Islands with Multi-Source Satellite Data

Simulation Of Thermal Effects Due To Different Amounts Of Urban Vegetation Within The Built-Up Area Of Beijing, China

A Satellite-Derived Climatological Analysis of Urban Heat Island over Shanghai During 2000–2013

Urban heat island analysis based on high resolution measurement data: A case study in Beijing

Study on Remote Sensing Retrieval of Urban Thermal Environment and the Temporal-Spatial Distribution in Beijing-Capital Zone

Air Advection Induced Differences Between Canopy and Surface Heat Islands

Study on the Urban Heat Island Effects and Its Relationship with Surface Biophysical Characteristics Using MODIS Imageries

Monitoring Intra-annual Spatiotemporal Changes in Urban Heat Islands in 1449 Cities in China Based on Remote Sensing

Surface and Canopy Urban Heat Island Disparities Across 2064 Urban Clusters in China.

Research on Beijing Urban Heat Island and PM10 in the Air