The arch support insoles show benefits to people with flatfoot on stance time, cadence, plantar pressure and contact area

Yu-ping Huang,Hsien-Te Peng,Xin Wang,Zong-Rong Chen,Chen-Yi Song
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237382
IF: 3.7
2020-08-20
PLoS ONE
Abstract:Pes planus (flatfoot) is a common deformity characterized by the midfoot arch collapses during walking. As the midfoot is responsible for shock absorption, persons with flatfoot experience increased risk of injuries such as thumb valgus, tendinitis, plantar fasciitis, metatarsal pain, knee pain, lower-back pain with prolonged uphill, downhill, and level walking, depriving them of the physical and mental health benefits of walking as an exercise.Fifteen female college students with flatfoot were recruited. A wireless plantar-pressure system was used to measure the stance time, cadence, plantar pressure, and contact area. Parameters were compared between wearing flat and arch-support insoles using a two-way repeated measures ANOVA with on an incline, decline, and level surface, respectively. The significance level α was set to 0.05. The effect size (ES) was calculated as a measure of the practical relevance of the significance using Cohen's <em>d</em>.On the level surface, the stance time in the arch-support insole was significantly shorter than in the flat insole (<em>p</em>&lt;0.05; <em>ES</em> = 0.48). The peak pressure of the big toe in the arch-support insole was significantly greater than in the flat insole on the uphill (<em>p</em>&lt;0.05; <em>ES</em> = 0.53) and level surfaces (<em>p</em>&lt;0.05; <em>ES</em> = 0.71). The peak pressure of the metatarsals 2–4 and the contact area of the midfoot in the arch-support insole were significantly greater than in the flat insole on all surfaces (all <em>p</em>&lt; 0.05).These results imply that wearing an arch-support insole provides benefits in the shortened stance time and generation of propulsion force to the big toe while walking on uphill and level surfaces and to the metatarsals 2–4 while walking on the level surface. More evenly distributed contact areas across the midfoot may help absorb shock during uphill, downhill and level walking.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper mainly explores the effects of arch support insoles on standing time, step frequency, plantar pressure, and contact area in individuals with flat feet. ### Research Background The paper points out that flat feet (collapsed arches) are a common foot deformity characterized by the collapse of the arch structure in the middle of the foot during walking. This foot deformity increases the risk of injuries such as hallux valgus, tendinitis, plantar fasciitis, metatarsal pain, knee pain, and lower back pain, and affects the physical and psychological health benefits of walking as exercise. ### Research Methods The study recruited 15 female college students with flat feet for the experiment. A wireless plantar pressure system was used to measure the standing time, step frequency, peak plantar pressure, and contact area between the foot and the ground when the subjects wore regular flat insoles and flat insoles with arch support on three different terrains: uphill, downhill, and flat ground. A two-factor repeated measures ANOVA was used to compare the parameters under different conditions. ### Main Findings - On flat ground, the standing time with arch support insoles was shorter than with regular flat insoles. - On uphill and flat ground, the peak pressure on the big toe was greater with arch support insoles than with regular flat insoles. - On all terrains, the pressure on metatarsals 2 to 4 and the contact area of the midfoot were greater with arch support insoles than with regular flat insoles. - Arch support insoles made the contact area distribution of the midfoot more even, helping to absorb impact when walking uphill, downhill, and on flat ground. ### Conclusion These results indicate that wearing arch support insoles can shorten standing time, increase the propulsion force of the big toe (especially when walking uphill and on flat ground), and increase the propulsion force of metatarsals 2 to 4 when walking on flat ground. Additionally, arch support insoles can increase the contact area of the midfoot, which is very important for patients with flat feet. These improvements may help reduce the impact force during walking and improve the comfort and stability of individuals with flat feet.