Abstract:Sitting alone with one’s thoughts could foster a sense of rest and relaxation, yet many find this activity difficult. In two preregistered experiments (Study 1: n = 266, Study 2: n = 369), we focused on autonomy-supportive and controlling framings of solitude as drivers of motivation for solitude, positive experiences such as enjoyment and relaxation, negative experiences such as frustration and boredom, and negative thoughts like worries and rumination. In Study 1, we found support for one hypothesis that autonomy-supportive instructions to sit alone with thoughts led to greater autonomous motivation for solitude compared to controlling instructions that pressured participants to sit alone. However, the effect of instructions on autonomous motivation was trivial, with a smaller effect observed in Study 2. More importantly, we did not find evidence that our autonomy-supportive instructions meaningfully influenced self-reported measures of participants’ experiences with sitting alone with thoughts, nor both self-reported and behavioral measures intention to be in solitude again. Examination of null effects suggested that most differences between autonomy-supportive and controlling-instruction conditions were likely too small to be practically meaningful. However, some null findings in relation to excitement, relaxation, or frustration during sitting alone with thoughts were equivocal and required larger sample sizes to determine whether there was indeed an absence of effect. Consistent with findings reported by Nguyen et al. (2018), participants displayed drops in high-arousal types of affect and increases in low-arousal types of affect. Future research is needed to explore other factors that influence motivation for solitude and lead people to benefit from the regulatory effects of time spent alone.

Seeking solitude skills: Do memories of intrinsic goals enhance enjoyment of alone time?

Alone With Our Thoughts: Investigation of Autonomy Supportive Framing as a Driver of Enjoyment During Quiet Time in Solitude

Investigating solitude as a tool for downregulation of daily arousal using ecological momentary assessments

Solitude as an Approach to Affective Self-Regulation

By myself and liking it? Predictors of distinct types of solitude experiences in daily life

Misremembering Solitude: The Role of Personality and Cultural Self‐Concepts in Shaping Discrepancies Between Recalled and Concurrent Affect in Solitude

Deconstructing Solitude and Its Links to Well‐Being

Who feels good in solitude? A qualitative analysis of the personality and mindset factors relating to well‐being when alone

Person‐specific priorities in solitude

In Solitude, I Seek a Better Me: How Solitude Affects Tourists’ Eudaimonic, Hedonic, and Behavioral Outcomes

The Effects of Multifaceted Introversion and Sensory Processing Sensitivity on Solitude‐Seeking Behavior

Time‐savoring moderates associations of solitude with depressive mood, loneliness, and somatic symptoms in older adults' daily life

The Many Ways of Experiencing Solitude: Personality Processes, in Context, as Predictors of Time Alone

Balance between solitude and socializing: everyday solitude time both benefits and harms well-being

Happy Alone? Motivational Profiles of Solitude and Well-Being Among Senior Living Residents

Need satisfaction in daily well‐being: Both social and solitude contexts contribute to well‐being

SOLITUDE LINKS WITH INDIVIDUAL AND RELATIONAL WELL-BEING: EVIDENCE FROM DYADIC DAILY LIFE ASSESSMENTS

Awe fosters positive attitudes toward solitude

Seeking more solitude: Conceptualization, assessment, and implications of aloneliness

Choosing Solitude: Age Differences in Situational and Affective Correlates of Solitude-Seeking in Midlife and Older Adulthood

Experiences of solitude in adulthood and old age: The role of autonomy