The Moderating Role of Country Governance in the Link between ESG and Financial Performance: A Study of Listed Companies in 58 Countries

Zhonghuan Luo,Yujia Li,Luu Thi Nguyen,Irfan Jo,Jing Zhao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16135410

IF: 3.9

2024-06-26

Sustainability

Abstract:Corporate environmental, social, and governance (ESG) performance is expected to positively affect financial performance because it helps firms gain sociopolitical legitimacy from receiving positive stakeholder awareness and gaining key resources. However, the research on the relationship between corporate ESG performance and financial performance has yielded mixed results. This paper explores the impact of the country governance environment on the ESG–financial performance link. We propose that the positive ESG–financial performance relationship is stronger for firms in countries with better governance. Empirical analyses using a large panel dataset covering 11 years and 58 countries support our arguments. We found that countries with more effective governance in political stability, regulatory quality, and control of corruption strengthen the positive ESG–financial performance relationship. The implications of our findings are significant for firms that face different governance environments and develop sustainable business strategies.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the impact of national governance environments on the relationship between Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) performance and financial performance. Specifically, the authors hypothesize that in countries with higher levels of governance, the positive relationship between corporate ESG performance and financial performance is more pronounced.

#### Main Findings:
- The study results indicate that in countries with political stability, high regulatory quality, and good corruption control, the positive impact of ESG performance on corporate financial performance is more significant.
- These conclusions remain robust after various measurement methods and country sensitivity tests.

#### Research Contributions:
1. **Clarifying Controversial Relationships**: By analyzing a large panel dataset from 58 countries over 11 years, the research reveals how ESG activities impact corporate performance differently across countries.
2. **Understanding the Role of National Governance**: It specifically elaborates on the moderating role of political stability, regulatory quality, and corruption control in corporate ESG performance.
3. **Empirical Evidence**: Provides substantial empirical evidence to test the link between ESG and financial performance, and further demonstrates the long-term impact of ESG performance on financial outcomes by analyzing data from 3993 companies over the long term.

#### Methodology:
- **Data Sources**: The study uses ESG score data provided by the Thomson Reuters ASSET4 database, combined with corporate financial data from Compustat North America and national governance indicators from the World Bank.
- **Sample Selection**: The final dataset comprises an unbalanced panel of 3993 companies from 58 countries between 2010 and 2020.
- **Variable Measurement**: Return on Assets (ROA) is used as the measure of financial performance; ESG scores as the independent variable; national governance indicators as moderating variables; and a series of control variables such as company size, leverage, etc.

Through these analyses, the paper provides important insights into sustainable development strategies for corporate managers and policymakers.