Abstract:Abstract Aims The theory of ‘what matters most’ (WMM) has been developed to understand differences in mental illness stigma between cultures, postulating that stigma becomes most pervasive in situations that matter most in a specific cultural context. The rise of populism in Western societies demonstrates that also within one cultural context, different values ‘matter most’ to different groups. We expand the WMM framework to explore the spectrum of stigma manifestations within Western societies, relating it to both conservative/authoritarian and liberal/modern values. From our findings, we will develop hypotheses on how further research into value orientations and stigma might address potential blind spots in stigma research. Methods Based on a narrative review of the literature on mental illness stigma and value orientations, we apply the WMM framework to cultural mechanisms of stigma within modern Western societies. Results There are several studies showing an association between traditional, authoritarian, conservative values with stronger mental illness stigma, while studies examining the stigma within liberal, modern value orientations are scarce. We hypothesise on situations where encountering a person with mental illness could threaten liberal values and thus might provoke stigma among persons with such value orientations. For example, living with a person with mental illness could be seen as consuming energy and time, thereby jeopardising ‘self-actualisation’, the modern value of realising one's own full potential. As a result, a person highly valuing self-actualisation might try to avoid contact with persons with mental illness. Instances of potential ‘liberal stigma’ also include structural stigma or self-stigma, when, e.g. changing assumptions of what is considered ‘normal’ increase perceptions of being fundamentally different when experiencing mental illness. Conclusions ‘WMM’ appears to be a useful framework to direct research to potential blind spots within the field of stigma research. Looking at instances where liberal values conflict with dealing with a person with mental illness could provide a more comprehensive understanding of stigma experiences among persons with mental illness. However, for measuring stigma, tapping into liberal variations of mental illness stigma is methodologically challenging. Qualitative work could be the first step to elicit potential stigma experiences based on conflicts with liberal values.

Stigma; Notes On The Management Of Spoiled Identity

Living as Socially Marked Individuals: Two Stories on Stigma and Its Consequences

Social Stigma and Self-Esteem: Situational Construction of Self-Worth

Stigma and Self-Stigma in Addiction

Rethinking the sociology of stigma

Evolutionary origins of stigmatization: The functions of social exclusion.

Research into Coping with Stigma: Retrospect, Current Theoretical Approaches and Prospect

Insights into stigma management communication theory: considering stigmatization as interpersonal influence

Tainted by Stigma: The Interplay of Stigma and Moral Identity in Health Persuasion

Stigma Beyond Levels: Advancing Research on Stigmatization

Transforming AIDS: The moral management of stigmatized identity

Stigma as moral insurance: How stigma buffers firms from the market consequences of greenwashing

Organizational Event Stigma: Typology, Processes, and Stickiness

Stigma, Stereotypes and Resilience Identities: The Relationship Between Identity Processes and Resilience Processes Among Black American Adolescents

Conceptualizing and Developing a Dynamic Stigma Theory

Blind spots in stigma research? Broadening our perspective on mental illness stigma by exploring ‘what matters most’ in modern Western societies

The identity group as a source of social influence for individuals with concealable stigmatized identities

Emerging Patterns of Stigma Management Communication Strategies Among Burn Survivors and Relational Partners

Psych Unit Gangs: An Autoethnography

The Catch-22 of Countering a Moral Occupational Stigma in Employee-Customer Interactions

Housing Stigmatization: A General Theory