Abstract:Abstract. Accurately determining the global minima of a molecular structure is important in diverse scientific fields, including drug design, materials science, and chemical synthesis. Conformational search engines serve as valuable tools for exploring the extensive conformational space of molecules and identifying energetically favorable conformations. In this study, we present a comparison of Auto3D, CREST, Balloon, and ETKDG (from RDKit), which are freely available conformational search engines, to evaluate their effectiveness in locating the global minima. These engines employ distinct methodologies, including machine learning (ML) potential-based, semiempirical, and force field (FF) based approaches. To validate these methods, we propose the use of collisional cross section (CCS) values obtained from ion mobility – mass spectrometry (IM-MS) studies. We hypothesize that experimental gas-phase CCS values can provide experimental evidence that we likely have the global minimum for a given molecule. To facilitate this effort, we used our gas-phase conformation library (GPCL) which currently consists of the full ensembles of 20 small molecules, which can be used by the community to validate any conformational search engine. Further members of the GPCL can be readily created for any molecule of interest using our standard workflow used to compute CCS values expanding the ability of the GPCL in validation exercises. These innovative validation techniques enhance our understanding of the conformational landscape and provide valuable insights into the performance of conformation generation engines. Our findings shed light on the strengths and limitations of each search engine, enabling informed decisions for their utilization in various scientific fields, where accurate molecular structure determination is crucial for understanding biological activity and designing targeted interventions. By facilitating the identification of reliable conformations, this study significantly contributes to enhancing the efficiency and accuracy of molecular structure determination, with a particular focus on metabolite structure elucidation. The findings of this research also provide valuable insights for developing effective workflows in predicting the structures of unknown compounds with high precision.

Bioactive Conformational Generation of Small Molecules: A Comparative Analysis Between Force-Field and Multiple Empirical Criteria Based Methods

Cyndi: a Multi-Objective Evolution Algorithm Based Method for Bioactive Molecular Conformational Generation

Small-Molecule Conformer Generators: Evaluation of Traditional Methods and AI Models on High-Quality Data Sets

ConfGen: A Conformational Search Method for Efficient Generation of Bioactive Conformers

Assessing small molecule conformational sampling methods in molecular docking

Regularized Molecular Conformation Fields

Computer Chemical Simulation— A New Method of Molecular Conformational Analysis

Conformational searching methods for small molecules. I. Study of the sybyl search method

Exploring conformational search protocols for ligand-based virtual screening and 3-D QSAR modeling

Modern Semiempirical Electronic Structure Methods and Machine Learning Potentials for Drug Discovery: Conformers, Tautomers, and Protonation States

An optimization algorithm for conformer generation based on the bond contribution ranking

First-principles molecular structure search with a genetic algorithm

Development and Comprehensive Benchmark of a High Quality AMBER-Consistent Small Molecule Force Field with Broad Chemical Space Coverage for Molecular Modeling and Free Energy Calculation

Sampling of conformational ensemble for virtual screening using molecular dynamics simulations and normal mode analysis

Molecular Gas Phase Conformational Ensembles

Data-Driven Parametrization of Molecular Mechanics Force Fields for Expansive Chemical Space Coverage

An Enhanced Comparative Molecular Field Analysis Method Using Genetic Algorithm

Direct molecular conformation generation

Simultaneous Optimization of Biomolecular Energy Functions on Features from Small Molecules and Macromolecules.