Abstract:Adolescence is increasingly viewed as a sensitive period in the development of substance use disorders (SUDs). Neurodevelopmental 'dual-risk' theories suggest adolescent vulnerability to problematic substance use is driven by an overactive reward drive mediated by the striatum, and poor cognitive control mediated by the prefrontal cortex. To this end, there has been a growing number of neuroimaging studies examining cognitive and affective neural systems during adolescence for markers of vulnerability to problematic substance use. Here, we perform a coordinate-based meta-analysis on this emerging literature. Twenty-two task-based voxelwise fMRI studies with activation differences associated with substance use vulnerability, representative of approximately 1092 subjects, were identified through a systematic literature search (PubMed, Scopus) and coordinates of activation differences (N = 190) were extracted. Adolescents were defined as 'at-risk' for problematic substance use based on a family history of SUD or through prospective prediction of substance use initiation or escalation. Multilevel kernel density analysis was used to identify the most consistent brain regions associated with adolescent substance use vulnerability. Across the included studies, substance use vulnerability was most reliably associated with activation differences in the striatum, where at-risk adolescents had hyper-activation in the dorsal subdivision (putamen). Follow-up analyses suggested striatal differences were driven by tasks sharing a motivational and/or reward component (e.g., monetary incentive) and common across subgroups of substance use risk (family history and prospective prediction studies). Analyses examining the role of psychiatric comorbidity revealed striatal activation differences were significantly more common in samples whose definition of substance use risk included cooccurring externalizing psychopathology. Furthermore, substance use risk meta-analytic results were no longer significant when excluding these studies, although this may reflect limitations in statistical power. No significant activation differences were observed in prefrontal cortex in any analysis. These results suggest striatal dysfunction, rather than prefrontal, may be a more primary neural feature of adolescent vulnerability to problematic substance use, possibly through a dimension of individual variability shared with externalizing psychopathology. However, our systematic literature search confirms this is still an emerging field. More studies, increased data sharing, and further quantitative integration are necessary for a comprehensive understanding of the neuroimaging markers of adolescent substance use risk.

Blunted Ventral Striatal Responses to Anticipated Rewards Foreshadow Problematic Drug Use in Novelty-Seeking Adolescents

Risk Taking and the Adolescent Reward System: a Potential Common Link to Substance Abuse.

Reward Processing in Novelty Seekers: A Transdiagnostic Psychiatric Imaging Biomarker

Determinants of Early Alcohol Use in Healthy Adolescents: the Differential Contribution of Neuroimaging and Psychological Factors

Neural Basis of Reward Anticipation and Its Genetic Determinants

Lower Ventral Striatal Activation During Reward Anticipation In Adolescent Smokers

Characterizing reward system neural trajectories from adolescence to young adulthood

High Impulsivity Predicting Vulnerability to Cocaine Addiction in Rats: Some Relationship with Novelty Preference but Not Novelty Reactivity, Anxiety or Stress

Extra-striatal D2/3 receptor availability in youth at risk for addiction

Neurobehavioral Precursors of Compulsive Cocaine-Seeking in Dual Fronto-Striatal Circuits

A Developmental Perspective on Facets of Impulsivity and Brain Activity Correlates From Adolescence to Adulthood

Meta-analysis and review of functional neuroimaging differences underlying adolescent vulnerability to substance use

A robust brain network for sustained attention from adolescence to adulthood that predicts later substance use

Adolescent Impulsivity Phenotypes Characterized by Distinct Brain Networks

Neural response to threat and reward among young adults at risk for alcohol use disorder

Brain responses during delay discounting in youth at high-risk for substance use disorders

Effects of familial risk and stimulant drug use on the anticipation of monetary reward: an fMRI study

Viral over-expression of D1 dopamine receptors in the prefrontal cortex increase high-risk behaviors in adults: comparison with adolescents

Who are those “risk-taking adolescents”? Individual differences in developmental neuroimaging research

High Impulsivity Predicts the Switch to Compulsive Cocaine-Taking

Corticostriatal Responses to Social Reward are Linked to Trait Reward Sensitivity and Subclinical Substance Use in Young Adults