An Analytic Hierarchy Process Method to Evaluate Environmental Impacts of In Situ Oil Shale Mining

Xiaorong Wang,Boyue Liu,Shaolin He,Hongying Yuan,Dongli Ji,Li Qi,Yang Song,Wei Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16041363
IF: 3.9
2024-02-07
Sustainability
Abstract:The great demand for oil shale resource development and the corresponding threats to the environment have resulted in the urgent need to assess the impact of oil shale in situ mining on the environment. In this paper, based on an analysis method developed by the previous literature and the Delphi technique, three secondary indicators and ten tertiary indicators were selected. The weights of the indicators at all levels were subsequently calculated. The results identify environmental capacity, groundwater risk and prevention, and cleaner production as having the largest weights in the indicator system. Following this, the typical three-level indicators with the largest weight and content related to carbon emissions were introduced in detail, and combined with the calculated weight of each indicator, the comprehensive evaluation index method was used to determine the comprehensive evaluation model for the environmental impact of oil shale in situ mining. The comprehensive evaluation model value, PA, of the target layer (the primary indicator) under two different heating methods, combustion heating and electric heating, were then calculated based on the oil shale in situ mining area in Fuyu City, Jilin Province, China. This study introduces carbon-emission-related elements into the three-level indicator evaluation calculation model, which is a more accurate and advanced comprehensive evaluation method.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper primarily addresses the comprehensive assessment of the environmental impact of in-situ oil shale extraction. Specifically: 1. **Research Background**: - The demand for oil shale resource development is increasing, but the accompanying environmental threats also need to be assessed. - Compared to surface retorting, in-situ extraction has advantages such as high recovery rate, good product quality, less land occupation, and is more environmentally friendly. 2. **Research Purpose**: - To establish a comprehensive evaluation model to assess the environmental impact of in-situ oil shale extraction. - To incorporate carbon emission-related factors into a three-level indicator evaluation calculation model to achieve a more precise and advanced comprehensive evaluation method. 3. **Methods and Steps**: - Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) combined with literature analysis, Delphi method, and comprehensive index evaluation method to construct a complete comprehensive evaluation model. - Determining the target layer, criterion layer, and indicator layer, and determining the weight of each indicator through expert consultation. - Constructing typical three-level indicators and their comprehensive evaluation model, detailing the three most important three-level indicators: environmental capacity, groundwater risk prevention, and clean production. In summary, this paper aims to provide a comprehensive and systematic assessment of the environmental impact during the in-situ extraction process of oil shale, offering decision-making support for the planning and design of oil shale development projects and environmental protection.