A comparison of the diagnostic capability of Kato-Katz and real-time PCR for the assessment of treatment efficacy of ivermectin and albendazole combination against T . trichiura infections

Gabriela Matamoros,Ana Sanchez,Ruben Cimino,Alejandro Krolewiecki,Rojelio Mejia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0012677

2024-11-24

PLoS Neglected Tropical Diseases

Abstract:Trichuris trichiura is humans' second most prevalent soil-transmitted helminth (STH) infection after Ascaris lumbricoides , affecting approximately 4.6 million people worldwide. Despite its sub-optimal sensitivity, especially in low prevalence and infection intensity settings, the modified Kato-Katz (K-K) is still recommended as a diagnostic method by the World Health organization (WHO) guidelines. Within a randomized clinical trial (RCT) comprising four treatment arms with two different anthelmintics, the present study reports an important secondary research objective to determine the diagnostic agreement between K-K and real-time PCR evaluating treatment efficacy against T . trichiura . The parasitological results were analyzed, including cure rates (CR) of a subgroup of 94 participants positive at baseline for T . trichiura eggs for both techniques. The single-dose albendazole (ALB) arm resulted in significantly lower CRs than experimental arms of albendazole/ivermectin (ALB/IVM) combinations. The overall diagnostic agreement between both techniques was 88.7% [κ = 0.8 (P<0.001)]. Concordance between eggs per gram and Ct values was moderate, with the discordance source likely stemming from lighter infection intensities. These findings indicate that real-time PCR is a suitable alternative for CR estimation in helminthiasis clinical trials. It also highlights the need to identify the most accurate diagnostic tools for RCTs, that would benefit from guiding principles to achieve harmonization across studies and are not necessarily the same as those used for epidemiological surveys. Clinical Trials.gov (NCT04041453) Trichuris trichiura , commonly known as the whipworm, is a parasitic worm that is transmitted through soil and primarily affects children in tropical and subtropical regions. The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends controlling this parasite by periodically giving benzimidazole medications in areas where the parasite is endemic. However, studies have shown that the efficacy of this treatment is limited against Trichuris trichiura . One major challenge in monitoring and evaluating treatment efficacy is the need for highly sensitive and efficient diagnostic methods. Some studies have investigated using multiplex real-time PCR to detect T . trichiura and other similar parasites, but few have tested its effectiveness in clinical trials. Our study aimed to assess whether real-time PCR could be used as a diagnostic tool in randomized clinical trials evaluating treatment efficacy. Our findings show that real-time PCR agrees well with traditional diagnostic methods and could be a viable alternative for use in these trials, provided that standard guidelines are established to ensure consistent use of real-time PCR techniques.

tropical medicine,parasitology