Developing an expert prognosis system of the reciprocating compressor based on associations among monitoring parameters and maintenance records

Yen-Ju Lu,Fang-Yun Tung,Chen-Hua Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jlp.2020.104382
IF: 3.916
2021-03-01
Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries
Abstract:<p>The reciprocating compressor is, in general, a critical equipment in a process plant. For certain ultra-high-pressure process, if the reciprocating compressor fails, often it will cause serious impact to not just the compressor itself, but also the process surrounds it. To prevent compressors from failures, an expert diagnosis system is needed. However, the traditional rule-based expert system is quite inefficient and difficult to create.</p><p>For an expert prognosis system that is customized to meet needs of a specific process, one needs to refer to plant maintenance history, which is hard to come by due to the fact that most maintenance was poorly documented. This research attempt to demonstrate the feasibility of developing an expert prognosis system through implementation of association rules. Rather than mining from maintenance history, records of failure cases were collected from technical journal articles by extracting information containing failure symptoms and causes on failed components, that mimicking repair history. In total, 115 failure information out from 41 journal articles were gathered. Applications of this approach to practical use in a process plant is easy by replacing the failure information table with that from datamining the repair history. The failure information was first tabulated and then put through association analysis for support, confidence, and lift between two parameters. The demonstration program has been successful with 1-to-1, many-to-1, and many-to-many analysis among failed components, failure modes, and operation parameters.</p>
engineering, chemical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inefficiency and difficulty in creation of traditional rule - based expert systems when predicting reciprocating compressor failures. Specifically, the paper points out the following deficiencies in traditional rule - based expert systems: 1. **Unclear relationships between rules**: The relationships and links between diagnostic rules are not clear, resulting in limited diagnostic capabilities of the system. 2. **Difficult to achieve automated learning**: Traditional expert systems are difficult to learn and update in an automated manner. 3. **Low computational efficiency and time - consuming**: In order to create links between rules, a large amount of searching is required, which makes the system run inefficiently. 4. **Difficult system maintenance**: Due to the complexity and large number of rules, the system is very difficult to maintain. 5. **Inference errors**: Errors are likely to occur during the interpretation and formation of rules based on empirical knowledge. To solve these problems, the paper proposes an expert pre - diagnosis system based on association rules. This system uses fault information extracted from journal articles to establish relationships between monitoring parameters, fault modes, fault causes, and faulty components through association analysis. This method can not only improve the accuracy of diagnosis but also overcome the above - mentioned shortcomings of traditional rule - based expert systems. ### Main contributions: 1. **Has the same inference function as IF - THEN rules**: The new system can perform inference like traditional IF - THEN rules. 2. **Overcomes the limitations of traditional expert systems**: By using association rules, the system can process large amounts of data more efficiently and is easier to maintain. 3. **Rapidly predicts possible fault modes, fault locations, and fault causes**: Through process parameters, the system can quickly predict the potential fault modes, fault locations, and fault causes of the equipment. ### Method overview: 1. **Establishment of the knowledge base framework**: A basic framework containing fault modes, fault causes, and faulty components was constructed according to popular engineering standards (such as API 618, ISO14224, and ISO17359). 2. **Data extraction and conversion**: 115 relationships between parameters and faults were extracted from 41 journal articles and filled into a table. 3. **Application of association rules**: The association relationships between monitoring parameters, fault modes, fault causes, and faulty components were calculated through three indicators: support, confidence, and lift. 4. **Pre - diagnosis**: Through association analysis, quantitative relationships between parameters, fault modes, fault causes, and faulty components were established, thereby achieving pre - diagnosis of potential faults. ### Key formulas: - **Support**: \[ \text{Support}(X \cap Y)=P(X \cap Y) \] - **Confidence**: \[ \text{Confidence}(Y|X)=\frac{\text{Support}(X \cap Y)}{\text{Support}(X)} \] - **Lift**: \[ \text{Lift}(Y|X)=\frac{\text{Confidence}(Y|X)}{\text{Support}(Y)} \] Through these methods, the paper has successfully developed an expert pre - diagnosis system based on association rules, improving the accuracy and efficiency of reciprocating compressor fault diagnosis.