Abstract:RNA post-transcriptional modifications play a crucial role in a myriad of biological processes and cellular functions. To date, more than 160 RNA modifications have been discovered; therefore, accurate identification of RNA-modification sites is fundamental for a better understanding of RNA-mediated biological functions and mechanisms. However, due to limitations in experimental methods, systematic identification of different types of RNA-modification sites remains a major challenge. Recently, more than 20 computational methods have been developed to identify RNA-modification sites in tandem with high-throughput experimental methods, with most of these capable of predicting only single types of RNA-modification sites. These methods show high diversity in their dataset size, data quality, core algorithms, features extracted and feature selection techniques and evaluation strategies. Therefore, there is an urgent need to revisit these methods and summarize their methodologies, in order to improve and further develop computational techniques to identify and characterize RNA-modification sites from the large amounts of sequence data. With this goal in mind, first, we provide a comprehensive survey on a large collection of 27 state-of-the-art approaches for predicting N1-methyladenosine and N6-methyladenosine sites. We cover a variety of important aspects that are crucial for the development of successful predictors, including the dataset quality, operating algorithms, sequence and genomic features, feature selection, model performance evaluation and software utility. In addition, we also provide our thoughts on potential strategies to improve the model performance. Second, we propose a computational approach called DeepPromise based on deep learning techniques for simultaneous prediction of N1-methyladenosine and N6-methyladenosine. To extract the sequence context surrounding the modification sites, three feature encodings, including enhanced nucleic acid composition, one-hot encoding, and RNA embedding, were used as the input to seven consecutive layers of convolutional neural networks (CNNs), respectively. Moreover, DeepPromise further combined the prediction score of the CNN-based models and achieved around 43% higher area under receiver-operating curve (AUROC) for m1A site prediction and 2–6% higher AUROC for m6A site prediction, respectively, when compared with several existing state-of-the-art approaches on the independent test. In-depth analyses of characteristic sequence motifs identified from the convolution-layer filters indicated that nucleotide presentation at proximal positions surrounding the modification sites contributed most to the classification, whereas those at distal positions also affected classification but to different extents. To maximize user convenience, a web server was developed as an implementation of DeepPromise and made publicly available at http://DeepPromise.erc.monash.edu/, with the server accepting both RNA sequences and genomic sequences to allow prediction of two types of putative RNA-modification sites.

Prediction of Protein N-formylation and Comparison with N-acetylation Based on a Feature Selection Method

Prediction of Protein Amidation Sites by Feature Selection and Analysis

A Method to Distinguish Between Lysine Acetylation and Lysine Ubiquitination with Feature Selection and Analysis.

Computational method for distinguishing lysine acetylation, sumoylation, and ubiquitination using the random forest algorithm with a feature selection procedure.

Investigation of Protein Post-Translational Modifications with Site-Specifically Incorporated Non-Canonical Amino Acids

Prediction of Tyrosine Sulfation with mRMR Feature Selection and Analysis

Prediction of Protein Lysine Acylation by Integrating Primary Sequence Information with Multiple Functional Features

Computational Prediction of Protein Arginine Methylation Based on Composition–Transition–Distribution Features

Computational method for identifying malonylation sites by using random forest algorithm.

Combining feature engineering and feature selection to improve the prediction of methionine oxidation sites in proteins

Computational Analysis and Prediction of Lysine Malonylation Sites by Exploiting Informative Features in an Integrative Machine-Learning Framework

Prediction of Protein Methylation Sites Using Conditional Random Field.

Prediction of protein N-terminal acetylation modification sites based on CNN-BiLSTM-attention model

Mal-Prec: computational prediction of protein Malonylation sites via machine learning based feature integration

Prediction and Analysis of Multiple Protein Lysine Modified Sites Based on Conditional Wasserstein Generative Adversarial Networks

Prediction and Functional Analysis of Prokaryote Lysine Acetylation Site by Incorporating Six Types of Features into Chou's General PseAAC

Prediction of Nitration Sites Based on FCBF Method and Stacking Ensem-ble Model

Prediction of Nepsilon-acetylation on internal lysines implemented in Bayesian Discriminant Method.

Large-scale comparative assessment of computational predictors for lysine post-translational modification sites

Predicting protein oxidation sites with feature selection and analysis approach.

Comprehensive Review and Assessment of Computational Methods for Predicting RNA Post-Transcriptional Modification Sites from RNA Sequences