Abstract:Thermodynamic properties are often modeled by classical force fields which describe the interactions on the atomistic scale. Molecular simulations are used for retrieving thermodynamic data from such models, and many simulation techniques and computer codes are available for that purpose. In the present round robin study, the following fundamental question is addressed: Will different user groups working with different simulation codes obtain coinciding results within the statistical uncertainty of their data? A set of 24 simple simulation tasks is defined and solved by five user groups working with eight molecular simulation codes: DL_POLY, GROMACS, IMC, LAMMPS, ms2, NAMD, Tinker, and TOWHEE. Each task consists of the definition of (1) a pure fluid that is described by a force field and (2) the conditions under which that property is to be determined. The fluids are four simple alkanes: ethane, propane, n-butane, and iso-butane. All force fields consider internal degrees of freedom: OPLS, TraPPE, and a modified OPLS version with bond stretching vibrations. Density and potential energy are determined as a function of temperature and pressure on a grid which is specified such that all states are liquid. The user groups worked independently and reported their results to a central instance. The full set of results was disclosed to all user groups only at the end of the study. During the study, the central instance gave only qualitative feedback. The results reveal the challenges of carrying out molecular simulations. Several iterations were needed to eliminate gross errors. For most simulation tasks, the remaining deviations between the results of the different groups are acceptable from a practical standpoint, but they are often outside of the statistical errors of the individual simulation data. However, there are also cases where the deviations are unacceptable. This study highlights similarities between computer experiments and laboratory experiments, which are both subject not only to statistical error but also to systematic error.

TAMie Force Field for Alkanethiols: Multifidelity Gaussian Processes for Dealing with Scarce Experimental Data

Transferable Anisotropic Mie Potential Force Field for Alkanediols

Physically motivated, robust, ab initio force fields for CO2 and N2.

Predicting Thermodynamic Properties of Alkanes by High-Throughput Force Field Simulation and Machine Learning

A Transferrable Coarse-Grained Force Field for Simulations of Polyethers and Polyether Blends

Parametrizing A Polarizable Force Field from Ab Initio Data. I. the Fluctuating Point Charge Model

Atomic permutationally invariant polynomials for fitting molecular force fields

Optimal Solution to the Torsional Coefficient Fitting Problem in Force Field Parametrization

Development of a fused-sphere SAFT-γ Mie force field for poly(vinyl alcohol) and poly(ethylene)

Simulation of Linear and Cyclic Alkanes with Second-Order Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory through Adaptive Force Matching

A Polarizable Valence Electron Density Based Force Field for High-Energy Interactions between Atoms and Molecules

Calculation of Transport Parameters Using Ab Initio and AMOEBA Polarizable Force Field Methods

Using physical property surrogate models to perform accelerated multi-fidelity optimization of force field parameters

Methodology of Parameterization of Molecular Mechanics Force Field From Quantum Chemistry Calculations using Genetic Algorithm: A case study of methanol

Benchmarking of Molecular Dynamics Force Fields for Solid-Liquid and Solid-Solid Phase Transitions in Alkanes

Force Fields for Deep Eutectic Mixtures: Application to Structure, Thermodynamics and 2D-Infrared Spectroscopy

Force field optimization by end-to-end differentiable atomistic simulation

Machine Learning of First-Principles Force-Fields for Alkane and Polyene Hydrocarbons

Learning Force Field Parameters from Differentiable Particle-Field Molecular Dynamics

Round Robin Study: Molecular Simulation of Thermodynamic Properties from Models with Internal Degrees of Freedom

A Scalable Molecular Force Field Parameterization Method Based on Density Functional Theory and Quantum-Level Machine Learning