Abstract:The adoption of novel molecular strategies such as genomic selection (GS) in crop breeding have been key to maintaining rates of genetic gain through increased efficiency and shortening the cycle of evaluation relative to conventional selection. In the search for improved methodologies that incorporate novel sources of variation for the assessment of genetic merit, GS remains a focus of crop breeding research globally. Here we explored the role transcriptome data could play in enhancing GS using wheat as a test case. Across 286 wheat lines, we integrated phenotype and multi-omic data from controlled environment and field experiments including ca. 40K single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP), abundance data for ca. 50K transcripts as well as meta-data (e.g. categorical environments) predicted individual genetic merit for two agronomic traits, flowering time and height. We combined phenotype and multi-omic data from both controlled environment and field experiments. This included ca. 40K single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), ca. 50K transcript abundance data, and metadata (such as categorical environmental conditions). Using this integrated data, we predicted individual genetic merit for two agronomic traits: flowering time and height. We evaluated the performance of different model scenarios based on linear (GBLUP) and Gaussian/nonlinear (RKHS) regression in the Bayesian analytical framework. These models explored the relative contributions of different combinations of explanatory variables; additive genomic (G), transcriptomic (T) and environment (E), with and without considering non-additive epistasis and the G x E effects. In controlled environments, where traits were measured under contrasting daylength regimes (long and short days), transcriptome abundance outperformed other explanatory variables when considered independently, while the model combining SNP, environment and G x E marginally outperformed the transcriptome. The best performing model for prediction of both flowering and height combined all data types, G x E and epistasis, where the GBLUP framework showed slightly better performance overall compared with RKHS across all tests. Under field conditions, we similarly found that models combining all variables were superior, with the GBLUP and RKSH methods performing equally well. However, the relative contribution of the transcriptome was reduced. Our results show there is a predictive advantage to direct inclusion of the transcriptome for genomic evaluation in wheat breeding. However, the complexity and cost of generating large scale transcriptome data are likely to limit its feasibility for commercial breeding. We demonstrate that combining less costly environmental covariates with conventional genomic data provide a practical alternative with similar gains to the transcriptome when environments are well characterised.

Feature engineering of environmental covariates improves plant genomic-enabled prediction

Enhancing winter wheat prediction with genomics, phenomics and environmental data

Data Augmentation Enhances Plant-Genomic-Enabled Predictions

Enhancing Genomic Selection by Fitting Large-Effect SNPs As Fixed Effects and a Genotype-by-environment Effect Using a Maize BC1F3:4 Population.

An Assessment of the Factors Influencing the Prediction Accuracy of Genomic Prediction Models Across Multiple Environments

Using machine learning to combine genetic and environmental data for maize grain yield predictions across multi-environment trials

Increased Prediction Accuracy in Wheat Breeding Trials Using a Marker × Environment Interaction Genomic Selection Model

Genomic Prediction from Multi-Environment Trials of Wheat Breeding

Using machine learning to integrate genetic and environmental data to model genotype-by-environment interactions

Genomic Prediction Enhanced Sparse Testing for Multi-environment Trials

Increased Prediction Accuracy Using Combined Genomic Information and Physiological Traits in A Soft Wheat Panel Evaluated in Multi-Environments

Exploring the potential of incremental feature selection to improve genomic prediction accuracy

Revisiting superiority and stability metrics of cultivar performances using genomic data: derivations of new estimators

Improving the Efficiency of Genomic Selection

Incorporating gene expression and environment improves genomic prediction of wheat traits

Genomic prediction by modelling genotype by environment interaction for yield in groundnut

Integrative multi-environmental genomic prediction in apple

Multi‐trait genomic prediction improves selection accuracy for enhancing seed mineral concentrations in pea

An integrated framework reinstating the environmental dimension for GWAS and genomic selection in crops

Global Genotype by Environment Prediction Competition Reveals That Diverse Modeling Strategies Can Deliver Satisfactory Maize Yield Estimates

Increased Predictive Accuracy of Multi-Environment Genomic Prediction Model for Yield and Related Traits in Spring Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)