A non-parametric method combined with surface flux equilibrium for estimating terrestrial evapotranspiration: Validation at eddy covariance sites

Xin Pan,Zi Yang,Yuanbo Liu,Jie Yuan,Zhanchuan Wang,Suyi Liu,Yingbao Yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2024.130682
IF: 6.4
2024-02-07
Journal of Hydrology
Abstract:Developing suitable evapotranspiration (ET) methods for different water supply conditions is a major challenge. As a diagnostic approach, the non-parametric (NP) method avoids the parameterization of resistances, while having the advantages of clear physical mechanisms and simple input data. However, the applicability of the NP method in arid areas, especially at short temporal scales, is controversial. To address this problem, a type of equilibrium ET estimation method, surface flux equilibrium (SFE), was introduced into the NP method to obtain a new approach for estimating ET: the proposed SFE-NP. The accuracy of the SFE-NP method was validated based on 30 globally distributed FLUXNET2015 eddy covariance tower sites, and its applicability and sensitivity were analyzed. Results demonstrate that the performance of the SFE-NP method in arid areas is satisfactory, involving a significant reduction of the ET estimation error of more than 24.00 % (relative error: 32.31 %; bias: 10.17 W/m 2 ) compared with the Priestley–Taylor (PT), NP and Surface Flux Equilibrium (SFE) methods. And the accuracy of SFE-NP method is similar to that of Surface Flux Equilibrium Maximum Entropy Production (SFE-MEP) method in the arid areas. Furthermore, in non-arid areas, the accuracy of the SFE-NP method (relative error: 14.45 %) was better than that of the PT method and similar to that of the NP, SFE and SFE-MEP method. The SFE-NP method should be used at the daily scale or longer. The ET derived by the SFE-NP method introduced more errors at the hourly scale (increased error: 12.15 W/m 2 ) than at the daily scale. Air temperature and land surface temperature were the most sensitive parameters in the SFE-NP method, particularly in arid areas, with their sensitivities under arid conditions being twice as high as those under humid conditions. The SFE-NP method can satisfy the requirements for ET retrieval under different underlying surfaces and water supply conditions, and provides a simple but efficient method for high-precision ET estimation.
geosciences, multidisciplinary,water resources,engineering, civil
What problem does this paper attempt to address?