The Patient–provider Discordance in Patients’ Needs Assessment: a Qualitative Study in Breast Cancer Patients Receiving Oral Chemotherapy

Chunlan Wei,Yao Nengliang,Wang Yan,Fang Qiong,Changrong Yuan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.13374
2016-01-01
Journal of Clinical Nursing
Abstract:AIMS AND OBJECTIVES:To explore the differing perspectives of patients and providers and their assessment of supportive care needs in breast cancer patients receiving oral chemotherapy.BACKGROUND:The patient-provider concordance in patients' needs assessment is critical to the effective management of cancer. Self-administered oral chemotherapy greatly shifts responsibilities for side-effect monitoring, symptom management and dose adjustments from the provider to the patient. Home-based care plans will be central to the effective management of these patients.DESIGN:A descriptive qualitative design was used.METHODS:A purposive sample of nine breast cancer patients, four oncologists and four oncology nurses were recruited in Shanghai, China. Semi-structured and in-depth interviews were conducted to collect data. A qualitative content analysis aimed at finding manifest and latent meanings of data was applied to analyse the information.RESULTS:Four themes of needs emerged from the interviews with patients and providers: information/knowledge, communication, social support and symptom management, but patients and providers only agreed on the assessment of symptom and side-effects management needs. Patients want more positive encouraging information from providers, but providers think patients need more information of efficacy and safety. Patients appreciate support from other peer patients with similar experiences, but providers think the support from families and friends are readily available to them. Patients discussed their spiritual needs, while oncologists see the need to improve patient adherence to medication.CONCLUSION:Breast cancer patients differed from their providers in assessment of healthcare needs. Further investigation of the relationships between patient-provider discordance and patient outcomes may guide interventions to improve care for cancer patients receiving oral chemotherapy.RELEVANCE TO CLINICAL PRACTICE:Oncology nurses should develop a holistic home-based care plan by exploring and integrating the discordance of needs assessment of both patients and health providers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?