Prediction of Junior High School Students' Problematic Internet Use: The Comparison of Neural Network Models and Linear Mixed Models in Longitudinal Study

Mei Tian,Qiulian Xing,Xiao Wang,Xiqing Yuan,Xinyu Cheng,Yu Ming,Kexin Yin,Zhi Li,Peng Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s450083
IF: 3.974
2024-03-16
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Mei Tian, 1 Qiulian Xing, 2 Xiao Wang, 2 Xiqing Yuan, 2 Xinyu Cheng, 2 Yu Ming, 2 Kexin Yin, 2 Zhi Li, 2 Peng Wang 2 1 Library, Shandong Normal University, Jinan, People's Republic of China; 2 School of Psychology, Shandong Normal University, Jinan, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Zhi Li, School of Psychology, Shandong Normal University, Jinan, People's Republic of China, Email Purpose: With the rise of big data, deep learning neural networks have garnered attention from psychology researchers due to their ability to process vast amounts of data and achieve superior model fitting. We aim to explore the predictive accuracy of neural network models and linear mixed models in tracking data when subjective variables are predominant in the field of psychology. We separately analyzed the predictive accuracy of both models and conduct a comparative study to further investigate. Simultaneously, we utilized the neural network model to examine the influencing factors of problematic internet usage and its temporal changes, attempting to provide insights for early interventions in problematic internet use. Patients and Methods: This study compared longitudinal data of junior high school students using both a linear mixed model and a neural network model to ascertain the efficacy of these two methods in processing psychological longitudinal data. Results: The neural network model exhibited significantly smaller errors compared to the linear mixed model. Furthermore, the outcomes from the neural network model revealed that, when analyzing data from a single time point, the influences of seventh grade better predicted Problematic Internet Use in ninth grade. And when analyzing data from multiple time points, the influences of sixth, seventh, and eighth grades more accurately predicted Problematic Internet Use in ninth grade. Conclusion: Neural network models surpass linear mixed models in precision when predicting and analyzing longitudinal data. Furthermore, the influencing factors in lower grades provide more accurate predictions of Problematic Internet Use in higher grades. The highest prediction accuracy is attained through the utilization of data from multiple time points. Keywords: problematic internet use, junior high school students, neural network model, linear mixed model With the advancement of technology and the progress of society, teenagers are growing up in an increasingly abundant material and spiritual world, facing progressively complex challenges. Technology has not only enriched their spiritual experiences but has also given rise to various issues, such as Problematic Internet Use (PIU). 1 In recent years, researchers have shown growing concern about the internet-related issues faced by teenagers, such as the chaos within "celebrity fan clubs" and the existence of grey industry chains, 2 as well as the addictive nature of online games. 3 Some researchers have also focused on implementing relevant countermeasures, including enhancing online safety. 4 The intersection of rapidly advancing internet technology and junior high school students, who are undergoing significant physical and mental changes, makes these issues even more apparent. Junior high school students possess a strong curiosity about the world, especially regarding new internet-related phenomena. However, their behaviors and values are not yet fully developed, and their ability to self-regulate is limited. Consequently, resisting the allure of the internet becomes challenging, and they are often easily captivated by new games and carefully designed information online. Additionally, junior high school is a period marked by heightened independence and rebelliousness. These students yearn to break free from parental and teacher control, seeking autonomy and adulthood, and the internet offers an environment that caters to such desires, leading them to be more prone to indulgence. 5 Nonetheless, there have been fewer studies focusing on the longitudinal changes in PIU among middle school students and the factors influencing it. In recent years, research methodologies like deep-learning neural networks have increasingly come into the researchers' purview. In contrast to traditional linear statistical analysis methods, which suffer from poor model fitting, neural network models can overcome these limitations and provide better model fitting. In the field of medicine, some scholars have compared the accuracy of neural network and linear hybrid model. Li et al compared the prediction accuracy of neural network and linear random effect mixed model in longitudinal data. The results showed that whe -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?