Abstract:Existing studies showed inconsistent results about whether and how attribution patterns differ across cultures. To generate a systematic understanding of the complexities of cultural variations in making causal attribution, we reviewed three different theoretical approaches in this study: the relative perspective of self-enhancement, the universal perspective of self-enhancement and cultural cognition, and found that each theoretical approach has received empirical support and informed competing hypotheses. Hence, the main goal of this study is to investigate the three theoretical approaches simultaneously using experimental data and explore how these approaches explain attribution behavior across cultures in a qualitatively different manner. In Study 1, we recruited participants from the U.S., mainland China and Hong Kong of China for an online experiment. In Study 2, we recruited participants from the U.S., mainland China, Singapore and Japan, and introduced alternative measures to assess attribution behavior. Results suggested that: a) attribution behavior can be influenced by both self-enhancing motives and cognitive processes, along with measurement instruments. Specifically, the cultural cognition approach was supported when attribution was assessed with Likert scales. In contrast, when attribution was measured by rank-order questions, the relative perspective of self-enhancement approach was supported; b) attribution decisions diverged within East Asian countries but converged between the East (e.g., mainland China, Singapore) and the West; c) acknowledging the idiosyncrasy of each cultural group and investigating each group as a separate cultural unit are necessary and important for theoretical development in attribution. Future directions and management implications were also discussed.

Culture, Causal Attributions, and Development: A Comparison of Chinese and U.S. 4-and 6-Year-olds.

The Development of Generosity and Moral Cognition Across Five Cultures.

How Culture Shapes Social Categorization and Inductive Reasoning:A Developmental Comparison between the United States and China

Culture and Cause: American and Chinese Attributions for Social and Physical Events.

Children's descriptive-to-prescriptive tendency replicates (and varies) cross-culturally: Evidence from China

Parents’ Ethnotheories of the Nature and Causes of Children’s Misbehaviors: A Comparison of Mothers Across Two Cultures

"Why did she do that?": Chinese children's preference for trait‐based explanations of behavior

What Observation Studies Can Tell Us About Single Child Play Patterns, Gender, and Changes in Chinese Society

Do future actions matter more than past deeds? Temporal moral attribution in U.S. and Chinese school-age children

Parents' ethnotheories of the nature and causes of children's misbehaviors: A comparison of mothers across two cultures

Cultural Variability in Young Children's Folk Intuitions of Free Will.

Causal learning, counterfactual reasoning and pretend play: a cross-cultural comparison of Peruvian, mixed- and low-socioeconomic status U.S. children

Unpacking Different Approaches to Understanding Cultural Variations in Attribution Patterns

Cultural Differences in Revaluative Attributions

Is it personal or is it social? The interaction of knowledge domain and statistical evidence in U.S. and Chinese preschoolers' social generalizations.

Chinese and American Children’s Perceptions of Popularity Determinants: Cultural Differences and Behavioral Correlates

Children's recognition of causal system categories across superficially distinct events

Robust, Source-Independent Biases in Children's Use of Socially and Individually Acquired Information

Patterns of Achievement Attribution of Chinese Adults and Their Sociodemographic Characteristics and Psychological Outcomes: A Large-Sample Longitudinal Study

How Parental Instructions Scaffold Young Children’s Learning Performance: A Cross-Cultural Comparison Between America and China

The development of social comparisons and sharing behavior across 12 countries