Abstract:BackgroundCircular RNAs (circRNAs) are those RNA molecules that lack the poly (A) tails, which present the closed-loop structure. Recent studies emphasized that some circRNAs imply different functions from canonical transcripts, and further associated with complex diseases. Several computational methods have been developed for detecting circRNAs from RNA-seq data. However, the existing methods prefer to high sensitivity strategies, which always introduce many false positives. Thus, in clinical decision-supporting system, a comprehensive filtering approach is needed for accurately recognizing real circRNAs for decision models.MethodsIn this paper, we first reviewed the detection strategies of the existing methods. According to the features from RNA-seq data, we showed that any single feature (data signal) selected by the existing strategies cannot accurately distinguish a circRNA. However, we found that some combinations of those features (data signals) could be used as signatures for recognizing circRNAs. To avoid the high computational complexity of the combinational optimization problem, we present CIRCPlus2, which adopts a machine learning framework to recognize real circRNAs according to multiple data signals captured from RNA-seq data. By comparing multiple machine learning frameworks, CIRCPlus2 adopts a Gradient Boosting Decision Tree (GBDT) framework.ResultsGiven a set of candidate circRNAs, reported by any existing detection tool(s), the features of each candidate are extracted from the aligned reads. The GBDT framework can be trained by a training dataset. By applying the selected features on the framework, the predictions on true/false positives are reported. To verify the performance of the proposed approach, we conducted several groups of experiments on both real RNA-seq datasets and a series of simulation datasets with different preset configurations. The results demonstrated that CIRCPlus2 clearly improved the specificities, while it also maintained high levels of sensitivities.ConclusionsFiltering false positives is quite important in RNA-seq data analysis pipeline. Machine learning framework is suitable for solving this filtering problem. CIRCPlus2 is an efficient approach to identify the false positive circRNAs from the real ones.

Computational identification of circular RNAs based on conformational and thermodynamic properties in the flanking introns

CircPro: an Integrated Tool for the Identification of Circrnas with Protein-Coding Potential.

Identification, Characterization, and Functional Prediction of Circular RNAs in Maize

IsRNAcirc: 3D structure prediction of circular RNAs based on coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation

CIRI: an efficient and unbiased algorithm for de novo circular RNA identification

CircCNNs, a convolutional neural network framework to better understand the biogenesis of exonic circRNAs

circFL-seq reveals full-length circular RNAs with rolling circular reverse transcription and nanopore sequencing.

A Comprehensive Overview and Evaluation of Circular RNA Detection Tools

An Efficient Algorithm for Sensitively Detecting Circular RNA from RNA-seq Data

Systematic identification and characterization of exon-intron circRNAs

Quantifying Circular RNA Expression from RNA-seq Data Using Model-Based Framework

3dRNA: 3D Structure Prediction from Linear to Circular RNAs

CircRNA identification and feature interpretability analysis

Circfl-Seq, A Full-length Circrna Sequencing Method

Predicting circRNA-RBP Binding Sites Using a Hybrid Deep Neural Network

A Machine Learning Framework for Accurately Recognizing Circular RNAs for Clinical Decision-Supporting

Modeling circRNAs expression pattern with integrated sequence and epigenetic features identifies H3K79me2 as regulators for circRNAs expression

Dynamic conformation: Marching toward circular RNA function and application

CircSLNN: Identifying RBP-Binding Sites on circRNAs via Sequence Labeling Neural Networks.