Abstract:The widely adopted techniques for regional crash modeling include the negative binomial model (NB) and Bayesian negative binomial model with conditional autoregressive prior (CAR). The outputs from both models consist of a set of fixed global parameter estimates. However, the impacts of predicting variables on crash counts might not be stationary over space. This study intended to quantitatively investigate this spatial heterogeneity in regional safety modeling using two advanced approaches, i.e., random parameter negative binomial model (RPNB) and semi-parametric geographically weighted Poisson regression model (S-GWPR). Based on a 3-year data set from the county of Hillsborough, Florida, results revealed that (1) both RPNB and S-GWPR successfully capture the spatially varying relationship, but the two methods yield notably different sets of results; (2) the S-GWPR performs best with the highest value of Rd(2) as well as the lowest mean absolute deviance and Akaike information criterion measures. Whereas the RPNB is comparable to the CAR, in some cases, it provides less accurate predictions; (3) a moderately significant spatial correlation is found in the residuals of RPNB and NB, implying the inadequacy in accounting for the spatial correlation existed across adjacent zones. As crash data are typically collected with reference to location dimension, it is desirable to firstly make use of the geographical component to explore explicitly spatial aspects of the crash data (i.e., the spatial heterogeneity, or the spatially structured varying relationships), then is the unobserved heterogeneity by non-spatial or fuzzy techniques. The S-GWPR is proven to be more appropriate for regional crash modeling as the method outperforms the global models in capturing the spatial heterogeneity occurring in the relationship that is model, and compared with the non-spatial model, it is capable of accounting for the spatial correlation in crash data.

Estimating spatial logistic model: A deterministic approach or a heuristic approach?

Local Linear M‐estimation in Non‐parametric Spatial Regression

Application of genetic algorithm in estimating origin-destination matrices of traffic network

Simulated Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Spatial Stochastic Frontier Model and Its Application?

Different Spatial Sampling Models in Geographical Analysis

Using Exploratory Regression to Identify Optimal Driving Factors for Cellular Automaton Modeling of Land Use Change.

Using generalized estimating equations to estimate nonlinear models with spatial data

A New Parameter Estimation Method for a Logistic Regression Model of Water Shortage Risk in the Case of Small Sample Numbers

Variable Selection of Spatial Logistic Autoregressive Model with Linear Constraints

A Logistic Regression Model with A Hierarchical Random Error Term for Analyzing the Utilization of Public Transport

The Classification Ability of Genetic Algorithm for Pestimation of Logistic Regression Model

Non-Iterative Multiscale Estimation for Spatial Autoregressive Geographically Weighted Regression Models

Variable Selection for Spatial Logistic Autoregressive Models

Spatiotemporal analysis of rural-urban land conversion

Spatial Interaction Modeling Of Od Flow Data: Comparing Geographically Weighted Negative Binomial Regression (Gwnbr) And Ols (Gwolsr)

Local Linear Estimation Of Spatially Varying Coefficient Models: An Improvement On The Geographically Weighted Regression Technique

Modeling crash spatial heterogeneity: random parameter versus geographically weighting

Geographically Weighted Regression Model-Assisted Estimation in Survey Sampling

A Two-Stage Estimation Method with Bootstrap Inference for Semi-Parametric Geographically Weighted Generalized Linear Models

Mixed Geographically Weighted Regression Model-Based Small Area Estimation

Estimation of Spatial Panel Data Models with Randomly Missing Data in the Dependent Variable