Abstract:The present paper is about three concepts which are crucially involved in Gaṅgeśa's interpretation of a Mīmāṃsā argument against the well-known design inference of the existence of God in Nyāya, namely the concepts “cognition” (jñāna), “certitude” (niścaya) and “doubt” (saṃśaya). According to Maheśa Chandra, the author of the Navya-Nyāya manual Brief Notes on the Modern Nyāya System of Philosophy and its Technical Terms, certitude and doubt are the two varieties of cognition. He illustrates the verbal expression of certitudes by means of declaratives and the verbal expression of doubts by means of interrogatives (functioning as polar or alternative questions). He notes also that different credence levels might be associated with the alternatives involved in a speaker’s doubt. A biassed question in the form of a tag interrogative might be an appropriate way to express such a doubt. In Western logic the idea to treat declaratives and interrogatives on a par, which is anticipated by the Navya-Naiyāyikas' use of the unifying concept of “cognition”, goes back to Frege’s distinction between the semantic content (the “thought”) of a sentence and its force and it was recently elaborated by Ciardelli, Farkas, Groenendijk, Roelofsen et al., the founders of a new branch in logic called “inquisitive logic”. In the present paper we will discuss Maheśa Chandra's succinct exposition of the Navya-Naiyāyikas' innovative approach from the perspective of this type of logic. As an offshoot of our analysis we will try to elucidate Gaṅgeśa's apologetic concerns about the well-known design inference of the existence of God in Nyāya and its liability to be vitiated by a dubious upādhi.

The Problem of Foundation in Early Nyāya and in Navya-Nyāya

"The Absence of the Difference from a Pot is Potness" - Axiomatic Proofs of Theorems Concerning Negative Properties in Navya-Nyāya.

An Indian Quasi-Fregean Theory of Number

Maheśa Chandra’s Exposition of the Navya-Nyāya Concept of “cognition” (jñāna) from the Perspective of Inquisitive Logic

Killing Gently by Means of the śyena: The Navya-Nyāya Analysis of Vedic and Secular Injunctions (vidhi) and Prohibitions (niṣedha) from the Perspective of Dynamic Deontic Logic

Simple Axioms for Local Properties

Ancient Quantifier Logic

Prioritized Norms in Formal Argumentation

An Axiomatic Foundation for the Logic of Inductive Generalization

Inquisitive Neighborhood Logic

Formalization of Aristotle's Topics

Logic for conditional strong historical necessity in branching time and analyses of an argument for future determinism

A logical theory for strong and weak ontic necessities in branching time

Language Heedless of Logic - Philosophy Mindful of What? Failures of Distributive and Absorption Laws

Vagueness and the Connectives

Logics of polyhedral reachability

A Logical Approach to Doxastic Causal Reasoning.

A Leibnizian Logic of Possible Laws

A Joint Logic of Problems and Propositions

Intuitionistic logic, dual intuitionistic logic, and modality

When Do Introspection Axioms Matter for Multi-Agent Epistemic Reasoning?