Corporate Tax in Europe: Towards Convergence?

Paulo Jose Regis,Juan Carlos Cuestas,Yang Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2015.05.030

IF: 1.469

2015-01-01

Economics Letters

Abstract:In this paper, we analyse whether there has been any convergence in statutory corporate tax rates within a pool of European countries. We find that there has been some degree of convergence; specifically we find four main convergence clubs.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Convergence in Corporate Statutory Tax Rates in the Asian and Pacific Economies

Yang Chen,Juan Carlos Cuestas,Paulo Jose Regis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ijfe.1546

2016-01-01

International Journal of Finance & Economics

Abstract:Countries in the Asia and Pacific region have shown many macroeconomic similarities during a period of economic integration. This paper argues that there may be one more macroeconomic feature to add to the list: strong statutory tax convergence. Using data on the statutory corporate tax rate in 15 countries from 1980 to 2014, we identify (i) a significant dynamic tax convergence pattern and (ii) three tax convergence clubs. The latter consist of the small tax haven economies of Hong Kong and Singapore, the East Asian countries (plus one) and the South and Southeast Asian and Oceania countries. These economies, within groups, have been reducing the tax gaps with their neighbours over time. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Corporate Income Taxation Dynamics: A Comparative Analysis of Portugal, Germany, Belgium, The Netherlands, and Luxembourg

Filipa Jesus,José Amorim,Catarina Cepeda

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm17060251

2024-06-19

Journal of Risk and Financial Management

Abstract:This study seeks to undertake a comprehensive analysis and comparison of the corporate income tax systems across select European Union nations, with a specific focus on discerning disparities between the individual income tax (IIT) and corporate income tax (CIT) frameworks prevalent in Portugal, Holland, Belgium, Luxembourg, and Germany. With an institutional theory lens, we applied document analysis to describe the distinctive attributes characterizing each tax regime within the purview of competitive dynamics and fiscal competitiveness. Despite inherent limitations stemming from challenges in accessing tax-related information and potential oversights regarding socio-political determinants, this study underscores the imperative of grasping the intricate interplay between tax imposition levels and broader economic development trajectories. By furnishing valuable insights into prospective reforms pertaining to Portugal’s corporate income tax architecture, this scholarly inquiry significantly enriches our comprehension of tax competitiveness within the overarching framework of the global economic environment.
Symphony or Solo: Does Convergence Exist in Environmental Taxation among EU Countries?

Zhengzheng Li,Zhongyang Sun,Kaihua Wang,Oana-Ramona Lobonț

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16177678

IF: 3.9

2024-09-05

Sustainability

Abstract:This study sought to ascertain the existence of convergence in environmental taxation among EU countries. By employing the sequential panel selection method and the panel KSS unit root test, it is demonstrated that the environmental taxation sequences in Luxembourg, Germany, Spain, France, and Cyprus diverge, while those of the remaining 22 countries converge. Similarly, the energy tax sequences of Croatia, Spain, Germany, and France are unstable, indicating divergence, while the remaining 23 countries exhibit significant convergence. Finally, transport taxes show a convergent trend across all EU countries. The convergence of environmental taxation can be explained by the catch-up and spatial spillover effects, and the non-convergence of a few EU countries is attributed to their minimal implementation of environmental goals. This study provides recommendations for improving environmental policies.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
Productivity effects of corporate income tax: Evidence from China

Hongsheng Fang,Xufei Zhang,Lin Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/twec.13328

IF: 2

2023-01-01

World Economy

Abstract:With a persistent global economic slump, governments encourage economic growth by expansionary fiscal policies through tax cuts. Total factor productivity (TFP) is an important determinant of corporate development and economic growth. Taking China's 2008 Corporate Income Tax Reform as a quasi-natural experiment, this paper uses data from China's A-share listed companies from 2003 to 2018 and difference-in-differences analyses to identify the impact of corporate income tax (CIT) rate changes on TFP. The findings indicate that reducing the CIT rate positively impacts corporate TFP through two available channels: corporate investment and human capital investment. Additionally, the effects of reducing the CIT rate on TFP are primarily significant in non-state-owned, smaller and more financing-constrained enterprises.
Common Corporate Tax Base and Effective Tax Burdens in the EU Member States

A. Oestreicher,T. Reister,C. Spengel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.59403/2bw6n2r

2009-10-05

Abstract:This article assesses the impact of a Common Corporate Tax Base (CCTB) as promoted by the European Commission and the related working groups on the effective tax burdens of companies in all 27 EU Member States. The results shall help to evaluate the economic consequences of introducing a harmonized set of tax accounting rules for EU-based companies. The proposals for a CCTB covered here include depreciation on intangibles, machinery, buildings, furniture and fixtures, simplified valuation of inventories, determination of production costs for stocks, treatment of costs for R&D as part of production costs, provisions for future pension payments, provisions for legal obligations, avoidance of double taxation regarding dividend income, and loss relief. The proposed options for a CCTB are applied to average EU-27 corporations of different sizes, as well as to model companies belonging to different economic sectors.
The Quest for a New Corporate Taxation Model and for an Effective Fight against International Tax Avoidance within the EU

Luca Cerioni

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54648/taxi2016038

2016-06-01

Intertax

Abstract:The European Commission’s Action Plan for a Fair and Efficient Tax System within the EU, and the subsequent ‘Anti-Tax Avoidance Package’ (ATAP), set out a number of short-term initiatives aimed at achieving an optimal corporate tax system and at fighting international tax avoidance within the EU. Pending the desired introduction of the Common Consolidated Corporate Tax Base (CCCTB) as a long-term goal, these initiatives have been considered as capable of stabilizing Member States’ revenues and of allowing corporate taxation where profits are really generated. Since specific suggestions made in the academic literature – namely, the suggestions for a ‘destination-based corporation tax’, for a ‘corporation tax 2.0’ and for a ‘new common consolidated tax base’ – have the same objectives, this article critically discusses these suggestions and it analyses whether they can be considered as more consistent or as less consistent with the common objectives than the Commission’s initiatives. It also elaborates the hypothesis for a solution capable of both collecting the key input offered by these suggestions and being complementary to the CCCTB.
Evolution of fiscal systems: convergence or divergence?

Paloma Péligry,Xavier Ragot

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ser/mwad070

IF: 4.058

2024-02-19

Socio-Economic Review

Abstract:Abstract We analyze the convergence or divergence of the diversity of fiscal systems after the financial crisis of 2007. Studying twenty-nine countries, we first document the evolution of the taxation of households, firms, labor, consumption, and capital. We identify three types of fiscal systems: liberal, intermediate, and high-redistribution, which can be ranked in ascending order of tax rates, confirming known typologies in the diversity of capitalism literature. Only the tax rate on corporate profits shows signs of downward convergence over the period. The other tax rates show rather signs of divergence. Second, a divergence is observed among the liberal and high-redistribution groups over the period. The European countries are converging toward the high-redistribution model, with the exception of Great Britain, which is moving toward the liberal model. Thus, the financial crisis seems to contribute not to the convergence, but to the divergence of fiscal systems.

economics,political science,sociology
Portugal-European Union convergence: Some evidence

Pedro Pita Barros,Nuno Garoupa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0176-2680(96)00015-8

IF: 2.343

1996-11-01

European Journal of Political Economy

Abstract:The convergence of national income to ‘European’ levels has been a topic in nearly all discussions about the Portuguese economy. In this paper we present an analysis of this convergence process from the early 1950s up until the present day, with particular reference to the potential change in the pattern of convergence after 1986. Two fundamental questions are addressed: (i) has Portuguese income shown a convergence pattern to European Union (EU) levels over time? (ii) Did this pattern change after 1986 when Portugal became a EU member? Our results suggest a positive answer to both questions.

economics,political science
Income convergence clubs in the Eurozone: a tale beyond the core/periphery divide

José García Solanes,Arielle Beyaert,Laura Lopez-Gomez

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/aea-02-2024-0085

2024-11-09

Applied Economic Analysis

Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to examine income convergence among the Euro members from 1995 to 2021. Design/methodology/approach This study uses Phillips and Sul's test (2007, 2009) extended by Lyncker and Thoennessen's (2017) algorithm jointly with β and σ – convergence analysis and a traditional growth equation. Findings This analysis identifies three clubs of countries in terms of gross domestic product (GDP) per capita with notable disparities between and within them, which implies that the theory of optimal currency areas has not been fulfilled. Originality/value These results rule out the core/periphery divide as presented in the literature to date. Finally, by estimating an endogenous economic growth model, this study finds the primary factors underpinning the differences between the three stationary states: labor productivity, physical and human capital, investment and international trade.

economics
Do Asia and Pacific Countries Compete in Corporate Tax Rates?

Y. Chen,W. H. Huang,P. J. Regis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13547860.2012.745239

2012-01-01

Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy

Abstract:Do governments in the emerging Asia and Pacific region independently set corporate tax rates? This paper answers the question and contributes to the growing empirical tax competition literature by (1) generating a predictable tax reaction function considering the lumpy' nature of economic geography; (2) using GMM to estimate the tax reaction functions using panel data of 14 countries in the Asia and Pacific region between 1980 and 2007. We find evidence of strategic fiscal policy interaction. Globalization has positive effects on the interactive policy setting. Country size has also positive effect but the effects are offset when the openness deepens. Furthermore, a substitution relation between capital and labor is implied. Overtime, countries in the Asia and Pacific region seem to become more competitive in corporate tax rates.
Decomposing Multinational Corporations’ Declining Effective Tax Rates

Javier Garcia-Bernardo,Petr Janský,Thomas Tørsløv

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41308-022-00157-9

2022-03-08

IMF Economic Review

Abstract:We develop a methodology to decompose the observed decline in multinational corporations' (MNCs') effective tax rates into several components and quantify the role of tax havens. We apply this methodology to the best available data for MNCs headquartered in the USA – from the Bureau of Economic Analysis – and in the EU – from Orbis – and we arrive at three main findings. First, we estimate that between 2005 and 2015 increased profits in tax havens directly explain only 29% and 1% of the 7% and 9% point declines in effective tax rates for US and EU MNCs, respectively. Second, we find that US MNCs have primarily benefited from domestic tax base reductions, most of which can be explained by sectoral changes, while the statutory rate has remained constant. Third, we show that EU MNCs have mainly benefited from falling domestic statutory rates and we observe similar patterns across EU home countries, host countries and sectors.

economics,business, finance
Global corporate tax policy space

Turalay Kenc,Emrah Ismail Cevik

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecosys.2024.101197

IF: 2.31

2024-03-02

Economic Systems

Abstract:This study investigates the economic growth implications of ongoing and prospective rises in corporate tax rates following G20 countries' minimum corporation tax agreement. We use a panel data estimation approach to examine economic growth rates and associated macro-economic variables of 42 nations from 1990 to 2017. To elicit more comprehensive insights, we make a distinction between advanced countries (ACs) and emerging market economies (EMEs) and different levels of growth using a quantile estimation approach. The results reveal that corporate tax rate rises depress growth, with a relatively sizeable impact for EMEs, whereas it is not statistically significant for ACs. At high quantiles of growth rates, the impact of the corporate tax policy on growth increases. These findings suggest a dual effect for EMEs with relatively high growth rates and symmetric growth effects of corporate tax changes, necessitating innovative policy prescriptions to address the negative growth impact of prospective higher corporate tax rates.

economics
Convergence in R&D Expenditure in the European Union: A Club Convergence and KMeans Clustering Analysis

Bernard Banyuls,José Carlos Vides

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13132-024-02496-6

IF: 1.815

2024-11-10

Journal of the Knowledge Economy

Abstract:This paper analyzes the existence of convergence clubs related to R&D expenditure among the twenty-six European Union countries during the period from 2005 to 2020. To achieve this objective, we utilized the methodology proposed by Phillips and Sul ( Econometrica , 75 (6), 1771–1855, 2007, Journal of Applied Econometrics , 24 (7), 1153–1185, 2009) in conjunction with the KMeans algorithm. To the best of our knowledge, this research is the first to combine these methodologies in this context. The results reveal the presence of three distinct convergence clubs within the European Union regarding R&D expenditure. These findings have significant implications for policymakers in terms of designing and implementing policies, as well as for understanding the level of development in their R&D structures.

economics
Income convergence in Central and Eastern Europe: Evidence from cross-country panel data analysis

Seboka Alemu,Beáta Udvari,Balázs Kotosz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1556/032.2024.00016

2024-10-04

Acta Oeconomica

Abstract:Abstract Recent research has suggested that unconditional convergence no longer exists. Thus, this study examined the income convergence among 11 Central and Eastern European (CEE-11) countries that joined the European Union in/after 2004 and Europe's four largest economies (Germany, France, the United Kingdom, and Italy) by using panel data from 1994 to 2019. For this purpose, it employed the beta (β) and sigma (σ) convergence approaches to analyze the dynamics of economic growth. Based on the findings, in 1996, the four largest European economies had a higher capital–labour ratio and GDP growth than CEE-11. However, by 2019, the patterns reversed. As for the regression results, there was strong evidence of unconditional β convergence between 1999 and 2019, at an annual rate of 11%, with the σ convergence and the fixed effect models further supporting income convergence. Moreover, although brief divergence occurred during various financial crises, the overall trend was a significant convergence of CEE-11 with Europe's four largest economies through higher relative GDP growth. This study contributes to the economic growth theory of income convergence across countries and highlights the importance of regional integration in enabling sustainable catch-up growth.

economics
Club Convergence in the Eurozone: A Look at Inequality Dynamics

Sofia Vale

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2024.111683

IF: 1.469

2024-04-01

Economics Letters

Abstract:This paper examines the convergence of eurozone countries' inequality indicators between 1995 and 2020. The Phillips and Sul (2007, 2009) methodology is used to determine the existence of convergence clubs. Our findings show that eurozone countries follow a similar trajectory in terms of the income of the richest 1% of the population and are divided into two clusters based on other inequality indicators.

economics
Public Country-by-Country Reporting: Corporate Law, Fiscal Law and the Principle of Unanimity

Wolfgang Schoen,Wolfgang Schön

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3914704

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The European Union is in the process to establish “public country-by-country reporting” as a new and wide reaching obligation for multinationals to disclose tax-relevant numbers to a global audience, going beyond the OECD consensus which combined cross-border exchange of reports with confidential treatment by tax authorities. From a legal and institutional point of view the main issue is the correct legal basis for the new directive under the European treaties. Is this a matter of accounting law – which would allow legislation by a qualified majority of Member States under Art.50 TFEU – or is this a matter of tax law – which would require unanimity under Art.115 TFEU? The article shows how the treatment of these issues has been driven rather by political than by legal concerns including a deliberate modification of the directive’s preamble in order to secure a majority vote under Art.50 TFEU.
Tax Policy: Impact on Business Development and Economic Dynamics of the Country

Igor Sopronenkov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46852/0424-2513.4.2023.14

2023-12-25

Economic Affairs

Abstract:"The optimal system, structure, and effectiveness of the tax system depend on many factors and are characterized by several differences depending on the country’s social and economic development. The purpose of the academic paper is to identify the features of the impact of the EU-27 countries’ tax policy on business development and economic dynamics to determine the differences in this correlation. Methodology. The statistical and regression analysis of the tax structure of the EU-27 countries is used in the scientific article to evaluate its correlation with economic dynamics for the period 2000-2022 based on the average values for the following periods: 2000-2005, 2006-2010, 2011-2015, and 2016-2022. The results demonstrate a slowdown in economic growth in the EU-27 in the long run from 2000 to 2019 and economic growth in 2021 to 2022 with no significant changes in the tax structure. The dynamics of tax revenues were revealed to be stable, despite their different shares in GDP. In general, it is possible to assert a low level of correlation between the share of tax revenues in GDP and the annual GDP growth rate. The established regression model shows only a 9% change in GDP dynamics depending on the change in the share of tax revenues to the budgets of the EU-27 countries. The research has identified three groups of countries by the share of tax revenues, by the share of taxes on income, profit and capital gains, and by the share of taxes on goods and services in the EU-27."
Corporate tax, R&D and export decisions: Evidence from European firms

Ioannis Bournakis,Desiderio Romero‐Jordán

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/roie.12771

IF: 1.234

2024-06-27

Review of International Economics

Abstract:The paper presents a unified framework for analyzing the impact of corporate taxation on R&D and exporting, considering firm productivity heterogeneity and sunk costs. We empirically examine three hypotheses using data from 7819 European firms spanning 2001–2014. We propose that: (a) an increase in corporate tax reduces the likelihood of innovation, (b) an increase in corporate tax reduces the likelihood of exporting, and (c) firms that innovate are more likely to enter foreign markets. On average, a high Effective Average Tax Rate (EATR) lowers the probability of investing in R&D and exporting by 2.3% and 1.41%, respectively. For firms with low Total Factor Productivity (TFP), the adverse effect of taxation on R&D investment ranges from 3.71% in our baseline analysis to 12.9% in our sensitivity analysis. Interestingly, while EATR positively influences the export decisions of high‐TFP firms, a higher EATR can reduce the export probability by up to 25.5% for firms at the lower end of the TFP distribution. Our findings demonstrate a causal relationship between firm heterogeneity and their capacity to mitigate the distortions caused by higher taxes. From a policy perspective, our results suggest that fostering innovation is essential for firms aiming to expand into international markets.

economics
Portugal in the European Union: The Limits of Convergence

Sebastián Royo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13608746.2013.801114

2013-06-01

Abstract:This article examines the integration experience of Portugal in the European Union in order to study how it has affected the country's fiscal policies in the decade prior to the global financial crisis, from 1999 to 2008. It focuses on three main variables to account for the difficulties that Portugal experienced in complying with the Stability and Growth Pact: institutions, ideas, and interests. The paper closes with some lessons from the Portuguese experience. The examination of this case will show that, to be successful, economic reform has to be a domestic process led by domestic actors willing to carry it out.

political science,social issues

Corporate Tax in Europe: Towards Convergence?

Convergence in Corporate Statutory Tax Rates in the Asian and Pacific Economies

Corporate Income Taxation Dynamics: A Comparative Analysis of Portugal, Germany, Belgium, The Netherlands, and Luxembourg

Symphony or Solo: Does Convergence Exist in Environmental Taxation among EU Countries?

Productivity effects of corporate income tax: Evidence from China

Common Corporate Tax Base and Effective Tax Burdens in the EU Member States

The Quest for a New Corporate Taxation Model and for an Effective Fight against International Tax Avoidance within the EU

Evolution of fiscal systems: convergence or divergence?

Portugal-European Union convergence: Some evidence

Income convergence clubs in the Eurozone: a tale beyond the core/periphery divide

Do Asia and Pacific Countries Compete in Corporate Tax Rates?

Decomposing Multinational Corporations’ Declining Effective Tax Rates

Global corporate tax policy space

Convergence in R&D Expenditure in the European Union: A Club Convergence and KMeans Clustering Analysis

Income convergence in Central and Eastern Europe: Evidence from cross-country panel data analysis

Club Convergence in the Eurozone: A Look at Inequality Dynamics

Public Country-by-Country Reporting: Corporate Law, Fiscal Law and the Principle of Unanimity

Tax Policy: Impact on Business Development and Economic Dynamics of the Country

Corporate tax, R&D and export decisions: Evidence from European firms

Portugal in the European Union: The Limits of Convergence