Abstract:China is in the process of establishing a national emissions trading system (ETS). Evaluating the implementation effectiveness of the seven pilot ETSs in China is critical for designing this national system. This study administered a questionnaire survey to assess the behaviour of enterprises covered by the seven ETS pilots from the perspective of: the strictness of compliance measures; rules for monitoring, reporting and verification (MRV); the mitigation pressure felt by enterprises; and actual mitigation and trading activities. The results show that the pilot MRV and compliance rules have not yet been fully implemented. The main factors involved are the lack of compulsory force of the regulations and the lack of policy awareness within the affected enterprises. Most enterprises have a shortage of free allowances and thus believe that the ETSs have increased their production costs. Most enterprises have already established mitigation targets. Some of the covered enterprises are aware of their own internal emission reduction costs and most of these have used this as an important reference in trading. Many enterprises have accounted for carbon prices in their long-term investment. The proportion of enterprises that have participated in trading is fairly high; however, reluctance to sell is quite pervasive in the market, and enterprises are mostly motivated to trade simply in order to achieve compliance. Few enterprises are willing to manage their allowances in a market-oriented manner. Different free allowance allocation methods directly affect the pathways enterprises take to control emissions. Key policy insights In the national ETS, the compulsory force of ETS provisions should be strengthened.A reasonable level of free allowance shortage should be ensured to promote emission reduction by enterprises.Sufficient information should be provided to guide enterprises in their allowance management to activate the market.To promote the implementation of mitigation technologies by enterprises, actual output-based allocation methods should be used.The government should use market adjustment mechanisms, such as a price floor and ceiling, to ensure that carbon prices are reasonable and stable, so as to guide long-term low carbon investment. In the national ETS, the compulsory force of ETS provisions should be strengthened. A reasonable level of free allowance shortage should be ensured to promote emission reduction by enterprises. Sufficient information should be provided to guide enterprises in their allowance management to activate the market. To promote the implementation of mitigation technologies by enterprises, actual output-based allocation methods should be used. The government should use market adjustment mechanisms, such as a price floor and ceiling, to ensure that carbon prices are reasonable and stable, so as to guide long-term low carbon investment.

Abatement technology investment and emissions trading system: a case of coal-fired power industry of Shenzhen, China

Estimating the Environmental Efficiency and Marginal CO2 Abatement Cost of Coal-Fired Power Plants in China

The Construction of Shenzhen׳s Carbon Emission Trading Scheme

Opportunity and marginal abatement cost savings from China's pilot carbon emissions permit trading system: Simulating evidence from the industrial sectors

The role of output-based emission trading system in the decarbonization of China's power sector

Emission trading scheme, technological innovation, and competitiveness: Evidence from China's thermal power enterprises

Declining Renewable Costs, Emissions Trading, and Economic Growth: China’s Power System at the Crossroads

When carbon emission trading meets a regulated industry: Evidence from the electricity sector of China

Emissions Trading and Technology Adoption: an Adaptive Agent-Based Analysis of Thermal Power Plants in China

Technology-side carbon abatement cost curves for China’s power generation sector

Have China's Emissions Trading Systems Reduced Carbon Emissions? Firm-Level Evidence from the Power Sector

How does the carbon market influence the marginal abatement cost? Evidence from China's coal-fired power plants

On Shenzhen Power Plants Carbon Emmision, Cost of Reduction and Quota Distribution

Aggregated Impact of Allowance Allocation and Power Dispatching on Emission Reduction

Evaluation of effectiveness of China's carbon emissions trading scheme in carbon mitigation

China's ETS pilots: Program design, industry risk, and long-term investment

Effectiveness of pilot carbon emissions trading systems in China

Emissions Trading in China: Progress and Prospects

Controlling GHG Emissions from the Transportation Sector Through an ETS: Institutional Arrangements in Shenzhen, China

Environmental and economic performance of China’s ETS pilots: New evidence from an expanded synthetic control method

Can Emission Trading Policy Help Restructuring Industry? A Case Study in Shenzhen of China