Composite cognitive endpoints with improved power to detect presymptomatic Alzheimer's disease treatment effects in APOE4 carriers: Findings from the Alzheimer's prevention initiative

jessica b s langbaum,suzanne hendrix,napatkamon ayutyanont,pierre n tariot,adam s fleisher,richard j caselli,kewei chen,carolyn langlois,david a bennett,eric m reiman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jalz.2011.05.2401
2011-01-01
Alzheimer s & Dementia
Abstract:We have proposed an Alzheimer's Prevention Initiative (API) to relate a pre-symptomatic Alzheimer's disease (AD) treatment's biomarker effects to clinical outcome in cognitively normal people who, based on age and genetic background, are at highest imminent risk of symptomatic AD. Here, we used longitudinal data from two cohort studies at the Rush Alzheimer's Disease Center to identify a new cognitive composite score that is sensitive to cognitive decline associated with pre-symptomatic AD to inform on the design of a randomized clinical trial (RCT) in apolipoprotein E (APOE) e4 carriers. Using a battery of 19-21 cognitive tests, the annualized mean-to-standard-deviation ratios (MSDR) of the change over time were calculated for the un-weighted sum of every combination of two to six tests for those who developed cognitive impairment (MCI or AD) in the five years prior to diagnosis. Measurements were adjusted for aging/practice effects using data from participants who remained cognitively normal. The best combinations were evaluated for construct validity. This optimal test combination was then examined in APOE4 carriers. The optimal combination of measurements that was selected to sensitively measure cognitive decline over time included Logical Memory-delayed recall, CERAD word list-delayed recall, category fluency, Ravens progressive matrices, and MMSE (annual MSDR =0.182847). A similar composite test was independently developed using data from a longitudinal cohort of cognitively normal PS1 E280A mutation carriers (Ayutyanont et al, ICAD abstract 2011). This composite score was also shown to be sensitive to decline in APOE4 carriers relative to non-carriers between the ages of 70 and 85. Using this composite cognitive endpoint, we estimate that 4,360/1,100 APOE4 carriers per group would permit us to detect a 30% treatment effect in a 24/60-month RCT, respectively. In this first phase of the process, we have identified a combination of cognitive tests to evaluate pre-symptomatic AD treatments in cognitive normal people at high imminent risk for late-onset AD, and have shown that a similar combination performs well in individuals at highest risk for early-onset AD. We will continue to develop and refine this approach in preparation for the pre-symptomatic AD/surrogate marker development trials proposed in the API.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?