Abstract:Highly simplified approaches continue to underpin hydrological climate change impact assessments across the Earth's mountainous regions. Fully‐integrated surface‐subsurface models may hold far greater potential to represent the distinctive regimes of steep, geologically‐complex headwater catchments. However, their utility has not yet been tested across a wide range of mountainous settings. Here, an integrated model of two adjacent calcareous Alpine headwaters that accounts for two‐dimensional surface flow, three‐dimensional (3D) variably‐saturated groundwater flow, and evapotranspiration is presented. An energy balance‐based representation of snow dynamics contributed to the model's high‐resolution forcing data, and a sophisticated 3D geological model helped to define and parameterize its subsurface structure. In the first known attempt to calibrate a catchment‐scale integrated model of a mountainous region automatically, numerous uncertain model parameters were estimated. The salient features of the hydrological regime could ultimately be satisfactorily reproduced – over an 11‐month evaluation period, the Nash‐Sutcliffe efficiency of simulated streamflow at the main gauging station was 0.76. Spatio‐temporal visualization of the forcing data and simulated responses further confirmed the model's broad coherence. Presumably due to unresolved local subsurface heterogeneity, closely replicating the somewhat contrasting groundwater level signals observed near to one another proved more elusive. Finally, we assessed the impacts of various simplifications and assumptions that are commonly employed in physically‐based modeling – including the use of spatially uniform forcings, a vertically limited model domain, and global geological data products – on key simulated outputs, finding strongly affected model performance in many cases. Although certain outstanding challenges must be overcome if the uptake of integrated models in mountain regions around the world is to increase, our work demonstrates the feasibility and benefits of their application in such complex systems. Most popular hydrological models, which are tailored toward reproducing stream discharge measurements, neglect or strongly simplify spatial differences in environmental properties and/or physical processes, especially those related to the subsurface. This may limit their ability to provide reliable and useful future predictions, especially in regions with considerable climatic, topographic, geological, and hydrological complexity, such as the world's mountains. Here, we developed a more comprehensive and explicit representation of an Alpine hydrological system that is based on established physical principles and extensive data. We then applied the model to demonstrate that historical stream discharge and groundwater observations could be reproduced acceptably. We further generated several additional versions of the model by replicating current standard practices in physically‐based simulation approaches in order to test their impacts on model outputs. We report high sensitivity in certain instances. Overall, our approach offers the possibility to test alternative conceptual models or hypotheses of system behavior, better understand the data requirements and degree of model complexity necessary to robustly simulate the hydrology of relatively data poor mountain regions, and ultimately deliver more reliable and holistic hydrological climate change impact assessments to policy and decision makers. A structurally detailed integrated model of two adjacent steep, snow‐dominated, geologically complex Alpine headwaters was developed and calibrated automatically Spatio‐temporal dynamics and interdependencies of snow, surface water, groundwater, and evapotranspiration processes were represented Systematically substituting commonly used subsurface simplifications into the reference model strongly affected simulated dynamics A structurally detailed integrated model of two adjacent steep, snow‐dominated, geologically complex Alpine headwaters was developed and calibrated automatically Spatio‐temporal dynamics and interdependencies of snow, surface water, groundwater, and evapotranspiration processes were represented Systematically substituting commonly used subsurface simplifications into the reference model strongly affected simulated dynamics

How Much Can We Gain with Increasing Model Complexity with the Same Model Concepts?

Investigating Dynamic Parameter Importance of a High-Complexity Hydrological Model and Implications for Parameterization

Uncertainty in High and Low Flows Due to Model Structure and Parameter Errors

Does a large number of parameters enhance model performance? Comparative assessment of common catchment model structures on 429 catchments

Model complexity and data requirements in snow hydrology: seeking a balance in practical applications

Grid Parameterization of a Conceptual Distributed Hydrological Model Through Integration of a Sub-Grid Topographic Index: Necessity and Practicability

Comparing The Hydrological Responses Of Conceptual And Process-Based Models With Varying Rain Gauge Density And Distribution

Similarities and Differences among Fifteen Global Water Models in Simulating the Vertical Water Balance

Investigating the Appropriate Model Structure for Simulation of a Karst Catchment from the Aspect of Spatial Complexity

Hillslope scale conceptualization of hydrological processes for data-limited catchments and hypothesis testing by systematic model comparison

Improving the Applicability of Lumped Hydrological Models by Integrating the Generalized Complementary Relationship

A brief analysis of conceptual model structure uncertainty using 36 models and 559 catchments

Integrating hybrid runoff generation mechanism into variable infiltration capacity model to facilitate hydrological simulations

Simulating Fully‐Integrated Hydrological Dynamics in Complex Alpine Headwaters: Potential and Challenges

The impact of hydrological model structure on the simulation of extreme runoff events

Behind the scenes of runoff performance

A Statistical Vertically Mixed Runoff Model for Regions Featured by Complex Runoff Generation Process

Determination of Red Blood Cell fatigue using electrodeformation

Effects of Conceptual Model Structure Uncertainties on Actual Evapotranspiration Simulation

African American Stepfather–Stepchild Relationships, Marital Quality, and Mental Health

Impact of rainfall spatiotemporal variability and model structures on flood simulation in semi-arid regions