The Role of the Intact Structure of Adipose Tissue in Free Fat Transplantation.
Yi Yuan,Chunling Chen,Shu Zhang,Jianhua Gao,Feng Lu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/exd.12631
2015-01-01
Experimental Dermatology
Abstract:Autologous fat transplantation is widely used in plastic and reconstructive surgery. Transplanted fat not only adjusts facial and body proportion but also improves surrounding tissues, such as the improvement in the quality of ageing skin and scars 1. The Coleman technique is recognized worldwide as the standard fat transplantation technique that achieves the best graft survival rate and stability 2. Its developer, Sydney Coleman, believes that the most important factor influencing the success of the graft is that the adipose tissue (the connective tissue and fat cells) maintains its integrated organizational structure. In Coleman's technology, the acquisition, purification and transplantation steps are all standardized to maximize the activity and integrity of the adipocytes and adipose tissue. If a significant number of dead or damaged adipocytes are produced in the process of fat transplantation, grafting is likely to be extremely poor 3. In the early stages of fat transplantation, before a sufficient blood supply is established, the graft relies solely on the infiltration of the surrounding tissue fluid to gain nutrition. According to Yoshimura's ‘three zones theory’ of cell survival, only adipocytes in the most superficial layer (about 300 μm from the graft surface) are in the ‘surviving zone’, while the rest almost all die within 24 h after transplantation 4. Although the Coleman technique is designed to protect the activity and integrity of the adipocytes, the majority do not survive. What then is the role of the intact structure of adipose tissue in fat transplantation? Grafting of cryopreserved fat is reported to be less satisfactory than with fresh tissue 5. However, a study comparing frozen and fresh fat for transplantation found no significant difference in the fat graft weight, volume and histological appearance 6. Although freeze/thawing was found to cause necrosis and apoptosis of adipocytes 7, an in vitro study by Pu et al. 5 indicated that cryopreserved and fresh fat had the same histological structure. Previous research focused on the effect of freezing on the viability of the adipocytes, not on the structure of adipose tissue. Freezing causes mechanical destruction of the cellular ultrastructure and of the cell membranes. While Mazur's two-factor hypothesis8 proposes that the harmful effects of freezing suffered by cells are the result of osmosis and ice formation, the effect of freezing on compound tissue is different. We tested the influence of freeze/thawing on the structure of adipose tissue. Inguinal fat pads from C57 mice were harvested and put directly at 20°C (without cryopreservative agents). After 3 days, the frozen adipose tissue was thawed at room temperature and evaluated histologically with haematoxylin and eosin staining, and by scanning electron microscopy. We found that there was no significant difference between the structure of previously frozen and fresh adipose tissue (Unpublished data, Fig. 1). We surmise that freezing adipose tissue is detrimental to the cell viability rather than to the tissue architecture. Thus, freezing adipose tissue under specific conditions could be applied to establish an inactive model of adipose tissue that contains dead cells but has a well-maintained structure. We hypothesize that the intact structure of adipose tissue, even when composed of dead adipocytes, acts as a scaffold for the graft and provides a cell niche for angiogenesis and adipogenesis. Further studies, both in vitro and in vivo, will be required to define the role of the intact structure of the adipose tissue in fat transplantation. Using the inactive adipose tissue structure model, the level of apoptosis, type of apoptotic cells and structure of the adipose tissue preconditioned by low temperature or freezing can be measured in vitro. The inactive adipose tissue structure can be injected subcutaneously into C57-GFP mice to allow the type, origin and distribution of the proliferated cells to be detected in vivo. It will be necessary to establish the following: (i) the optimal temperature and duration of treatment to kill all cells in the adipose tissue while keeping the structure intact; and (ii) the type and origin of cells that contribute to adipogenesis after fat transplantation. The cell niche refers to the biologic, chemical and physical microenvironment surrounding cells that allows them to survive, grow, differentiate and reproduce 9, 10. Adipose-derived stem cells (ASCs) reside in a perivascular niche, which provides signals that balance the maintenance of ASCs in an undifferentiated state with their commitment towards a differentiated fate. Fat transplantation changes the parameters of the ASC niche and affects the fate of the ASCs. Maintaining an intact adipose tissue structure may be important for maintenance of the ASC niche. After free fat transplantation, an intact adipose tissue structure, even when it is composed of dead adipocytes, is the support for the fat graft, providing the cell niche for angiogenesis and adipogenesis. Fat tissue frozen under appropriate conditions could act as a model of intact fat tissue structure containing only dead cells with which to test the hypothesis. This research project was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (81171834, 81372083, 81201482 and 30901566), the National Natural Science Foundation of Guangdong Province (S2012010009370), the Science and Technology Program of Guangdong Province (2011B061300015), the Science and Technology Key Program of Guangzhou (11C32120716), the Specialized Research Fund for Doctoral Program of Higher Education (20114433120007) and the Foundation of Nanfang Hospital President (2011C008). Yi Yuan, Jianhua Gao and Feng Lu performed conception and design, collection and analysis of data and manuscript writing. Chunling Chen and Shu Zhang collected the data. The authors have declared no conflicting interests.