Abstract:QED in three dimensions with an $SU(2)_f$ doublet $\psi^i$ of massless, charge-1 Dirac fermions (and no Chern-Simons term) has a $U(2) = (SU(2)_f \times U(1)_m)/\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry that acts on gauge-invariant local operators, including monopole operators charged under $U(1)_m$. We establish that there are only two possible IR scenarios: either the theory flows to a CFT with $U(2)$ symmetry (a scenario strongly constrained by conformal bootstrap bounds); or it spontaneously breaks $U(2) \to U(1)$ via the condensation of a monopole operator of smallest $U(1)_m$ charge, which is a $U(2)$ doublet. This leads to three Nambu-Goldstone bosons described by a sigma model into a squashed three-sphere $S^3$ with $U(2)$ isometry. We further show that the conventional $SU(2)_f$-triplet order parameter $i \bar \psi \vec \sigma \, \psi$ also gets a vev, exactly aligned with the monopole vev, such that the triplet parametrizes the $\mathbb{CP}^1$ base of the $S^3$ Hopf bundle, with the monopoles providing the $S^1$ fibers. We also recall why this scenario is compatible with the Vafa-Witten theorem. We obtain these results by analyzing the phase diagram as a function of the fermion triplet mass $\vec m$: we show that for all $\vec m \neq 0$ there is a Coulomb phase with only a weakly-coupled photon at low energies, arising from a monopole vev that is aligned with $\vec m$ via the Hopf map. We then argue that taking $\vec m \to 0$ leads to the symmetry-breaking scenario above. Throughout, we give a detailed account of anomaly matching, which leads to a $\theta=\pi$ term in the $S^3$ sigma model. In one presentation, it can be understood as a Hopf term in a suitably gauged version of the $\mathbb{CP}^1$ sigma model.

Amending the Vafa–Witten Theorem

Amended Proof of Pitaevskii-Stringari's Theorem

A Confining String Theory Derivable from Yang-Mills Theory due to a Novel Vacuum Condensate

Axions and Superfluidity in Weyl Semimetals

Topological charge membranes and Goldstone boson propagation in QCD

Spontaneous Parity Violation in QCD At Finite Temperature: On the Inapplicability of the Vafa-Witten Theorem

Some Unfinished Thoughts on Strong Yukawa Couplings

Vacuum Condensates and the Anomalous Magnetic Moment of a Dirac Fermion

The strong CP problem revisited and solved by the gauge group topology

Symmetry Breaking from Monopole Condensation in QED$_3$

Electromagnetism in Quark-Antiquark Bound States

Abelian Magnetic Monopole Dominance in Quark Confinement

Goldstone bosons in the massless Thirring model. Witten's criterion

Quantized axial charge of staggered fermions and the chiral anomaly

Massive gauge particles versus Goldstone bosons in non-Hermitian non-Abelian gauge theory

Kaon condensation and Goldstone's theorem

Dyson–Schwinger Equation and Quantum Phase Transitions in Massless QCD

On the symmetries of elementary fermions

Anomalies and Dynamics in Strongly-Coupled Gauge Theories, New Criteria for Different Phases, and a Lesson from Supersymmetric Gauge Theories

Equivalence Theorem and Probing the Electroweak Symmetry-Breaking Sector

A theorem on vacuum stability