Abstract:The frequency and severity of traffic crashes have commonly been used as indicators of crash risk on transport networks. Comprehensive modeling of crash risk should account for both frequency and injury severity-capturing both the extent and intensity of transport risk for designing effective safety improvement programs. Previous research has revealed that crashes are correlated across severity categories because of the combined influence of risk factors, observed or unobserved. Moreover, crashes are the outcomes of a multitude of factors related to roadway design, traffic operations, pavement conditions, driver behavior, human factors, and environmental characteristics, or in more general terms: factors reflect both engineering and non-engineering risk sources. Perhaps not surprisingly, engineering risk sources have dominated the list of variables in the mainstream modeling of crashes whereas non-engineering sources, in particular, behavioral factors, are crucially omitted. It is plausible to assume that crash contributing factors from the same risk source affect crashes in a similar manner, but their influences vary across different risk sources. Conventional crash frequency modeling hypothesizes that the total crash count at any roadway site is well-approximated by a single risk source to which several explanatory variables contribute collaboratively. The conventional formulation is not capable of accounting for variations between risk sources; therefore, is unable to discriminate distinct impacts between engineering variables and non-engineering variables. To address this shortcoming, this study contributes to the development of multivariate multiple risk source regression, a robust modeling technique to model crash frequency and severity simultaneously. The multivariate multiple risk source regression method applied in this study can effectively capture the correlation between severity levels of crash counts while identifyinging the varying effects of crash contributing factors originated from distinct sources. Using crashes on Wisconsin rural two-lane highways, two risk sources - engineering and behavioral - were employed to develop proposed models. The modeling results were compared with a single equation negative binomial (NB) model, and a univariate multiple risk source model. The results show that the multivariate multiple risk source model significantly outperforms the other models in terms of statistical fit across several measures. The study demonstrates a unique approach to explicitly incorporating behavioral factors into crash prediction models while taking crash severity into consideration. More importantly, the parameter estimates provide more insight into the distinct sources of crash risk, which can be used to further inform safety practitioners and guide roadway improvement programs.

A Crash Severity-Based Black Spot Identification Model

Applying a joint model of crash count and crash severity to identify road segments with high risk of fatal and serious injury crashes

Hotspot identification considering daily variability of traffic flow and crash record: A case study

Analysis of black spot for freeway based on both statistics and hypothesis testing

Experimental evaluation of hotspot identification methods

Modeling crash severity by considering risk indicators of driver and roadway: A Bayesian network approach

Research on Identification of Black Spot and Accident Inducing Factor for Freeway

Comparisons on Methods for Identifying Accident Black Spots Using Vehicle Kinetic Parameters Collected from Road Experiments

Application of Poisson random effect models for highway network screening

Comparative Evaluation of Crash Hotspot Identification Methods: Empirical Bayes vs. Potential for Safety Improvement Using Variants of Negative Binomial Models

Identification of Black Spots on Highways Using Fault Tree Analysis and Vehicle Safety Boundaries

Identification of Significant Factors in Fatal-Injury Highway Crashes Using Genetic Algorithm and Neural Network

Investigating road conditions of crash blackspots in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia: a random parameters negative binomial model

Spatial multiresolution analysis approach to identify crash hotspots and estimate crash risk

Model Applied to Analyze the Traffic Accident's Causes on Black-Spot of Freeway

A two-phase clustering approach for traffic accident black spots identification: integrated GIS-based processing and HDBSCAN model

Assessing the Negative Binomial-Lindley model for crash hotspot identification: Insights from Monte Carlo simulation analysis

Study on Road Traffic Accident Black Spot Identification Method

Incorporating behavioral variables into crash count prediction by severity: A multivariate multiple risk source approach

Development of crash-severity-index models for the measurement of work zone risk levels

Short-Term Segment-Level Crash Risk Prediction Using Advanced Data Modeling with Proactive and Reactive Crash Data