Comparison of Three Pretreatment Methods for the Analysis of Distributions and Hydrogen Isotopic Compositions of Leaf Wax N-Fatty Acids in Natural Samples

Yuan Yao,Weiguo Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/rcm.7141
2015-01-01
Abstract:RATIONALE: The hydrogen isotopic compositions (delta H-2 values) of leaf wax n-fatty acids (n-FAs) are widely used as powerful biomarkers in biogeochemical and paleoenvironmental studies. However, the use of a variety of pretreatment methods to isolate n-FAs from natural samples for the measurement of delta H-2 values potentially causes discrepancies in the measured delta H-2 values, thereby confounding their use as a biomarker.METHODS: We tested three typical pretreatment methods for the analysis of the distributions and delta H-2 values of n-FAs from terrestrial higher plants (Carex siderosticta Hance and Ilex chinensis Sim), surface soil, and lacustrine sediment. Method 1 employed an aminopropyl-bonded solid phase to selectively separate free n-FAs from extractable lipids, while Methods 2 and 3 involved alkali-and acid-catalysed chemical reactions in extractable lipids prior to isolation of the n-FAs.RESULTS: Methods 2 and 3 yielded higher amounts of C-16-C-24 n-FAs and of certain long-chain n-FAs than Method 1 due to the release of the corresponding ester-bound n-FAs by saponification and transesterification reactions, respectively. Although additional ester-bound n-FAs were recovered by Methods 2 and 3, there were no significant differences in the delta H-2 results for all homologous n-FAs from the two plants and for mid- and long-chain n-FAs from the soil and sediment among the three pretreatment methods.CONCLUSIONS: Our study indicates that the three different pretreatment methods might not seriously influence the interpretations of delta H-2 values of sedimentary long-chain n-FAs as a terrestrial paleohydrological proxy; however, the release of ester-bound n-FAs by alkali-and acid-catalysed chemical reactions means that users should be cautious when interpreting and comparing distribution data of n-FAs from natural samples with different pretreatment protocols. Copyright (C) 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?