Abstract:Introduction Cognitive Map Theory predicts that the hippocampus (HPC) plays a specialized, time-invariant role in supporting allocentric spatial memory, while Standard Consolidation Theory makes the competing prediction that the HPC plays a time-limited role, with more remote memories gaining independence of HPC function. These theories, however, are largely informed by the results of laboratory-based tests that are unlikely to simulate the demands of representing real-world environments in humans. Validation of these theories is further limited by an overall focus on spatial memory of newly encountered environments and on individuals with extensive lesions to the HPC and to surrounding medial temporal lobe (MTL) regions. The current study incorporates naturalistic tests of spatial memory based on recently and remotely encountered environments navigated by individuals with lesions to the HPC/MTL or that are limited to the HPC's major output, the fornix. Methods Four participants with bilateral HPC/MTL and/or fornix lesions drew sketch maps of recently and remotely experienced neighbourhoods and houses. Tests of the appearance, distances, and routes between landmarks from the same real-world environments were also administered. Performance on the tasks was compared to that of control participants closely matched in terms of exposure to the same neighbourhoods and home environments as well as to actual maps. Results The performance of individuals with fornix/MTL lesions was found to be largely comparable to that of controls on objective tests of spatial memory, other than one case who was impaired on remote and recent conditions for several tasks. The nature of deficits in recent and remote spatial memory were further revealed on house floorplan drawings, which contained spatial distortions, room/structure transpositions, and omissions, and on neighbourhood sketch maps, which were intact in terms of overall layout but sparse in details such as landmarks. Conclusion Lab-based tests of spatial memory of newly learned environments are unlikely to fully capture patterns of spared and impaired representations of real-world environments (e.g., peripheral features, configurations). Naturalistic tasks, including generative drawing tasks, indicate that contrary to Cognitive Map Theory, neither HPC nor MTL are critical for allocentric gross representations of large-scale environments. Conversely, the HPC appears critical for representing detailed spatial information of local naturalistic environments and environmental objects regardless of the age of the memory, contrary to Standard Consolidation Theory.

Differential effects of bilateral hippocampal CA3 damage on the implicit learning and recognition of complex event sequences

The effect of hippocampal subfield damage on rapid temporal integration through statistical learning and associative inference

Differential effects of damage within the hippocampal region on memory for a natural, nonspatial Odor-Odor Association.

Differential contributions of the hippocampal dentate gyrus and cornu ammonis 1 subfield to mnemonic discrimination

The hippocampus and implicit memory

Memory Lost and Regained Following Bilateral Hippocampal Damage

Comparative effects of excitotoxic lesions of the hippocampus and septum/diagonal band on conditional visual discrimination and spatial learning

The Human Medial Temporal Lobe Is Necessary for Remembering Durations within a Sequence of Events but Not Durations of Individual Events

Item Recognition is Less Impaired Than Recall and Associative Recognition in A Patient with Selective Hippocampal Damage

Evidence for the incorporation of temporal duration information in human hippocampal long-term memory sequence representations

Conditional discriminations based on external and internal cues in rats with cytotoxic hippocampal lesions.

Impaired associative memory in temporal lobe epilepsy subjects after lesions of hippocampus, parahippocampal gyrus, and amygdala

Mammillothalamic Disconnection Alters Hippocampocortical Oscillatory Activity and Microstructure: Implications for Diencephalic Amnesia

Long-term retention of real-world experiences in a patient with profound amnesia

Associative recognition in a patient with selective hippocampal lesions and relatively normal item recognition.

Memory, Visual Discrimination Performance, and the Human Hippocampus

Time-dependent reorganization of brain circuitry underlying long-term memory storage

Impoverished details with preserved gist in remote and recent spatial memory following hippocampal and fornix lesions

The hippocampus, time and working memory

Hippocampal lesions impair non‐navigational spatial memory in macaques

En route to delineating hippocampal roles in spatial learning