Abstract:The delivery performance of complex engineering projects, such as infrastructure projects, is poor and shows no sign of significant improvement. Most of these projects have been delivered by a contractor organization for a client usually a public or statutory agency. To ensure expected outcomes, the client typically employs "control instruments", such as specifying outputs, directing behaviors, selecting contractors and building relationships, to influence, or control, delivery by the contractors. The dominant literature informing the choice of control instruments is derived from organizational control theory, which primarily focuses on the exercise of control within a single organization and assumes that different types of control function independently. The persistent poor delivery performance of infrastructure projects suggests a need to revisit the recommendations of organizational control theory. While a number of papers have identified the potential of combining control instruments and the need to take into account the influence of operating in a client contractor context the mechanics and influence of specific interactions remain little understood.A case study of the delivery of the Open Pool Australian Lightwater reactor (OPAL) Nuclear Research Reactor Project in Australia, documents how the various controls employed interacted and jointly impacted on the delivery outcome. The findings start the process of further developing control theory and offer a number of practical suggestions for combining control types for practitioners.There are two main contributions to theory by this study. First, it adds support to the view that the factors influencing the principal's choice of control modes are more complex than depicted by the control theory framework. Second, it enriches the emerging balance of control literature (Cardinal et al. 2004), suggesting that it is not only the number of control modes that determines performance but also the interactions between them. Thus not only is the appropriate choice of control modes based on more than task programmability and outcome measurability, it appears that interactions between control modes also play an important role. In the case studied a combination of input, output and clan control was seen as forming an effective combination. It was also assessed to be important to avoid behavior control due to the interaction effect between behavior control and output control when employing such a grouping. (C) 2014 Elsevier Ltd. APM and IPMA. All rights reserved.

Computational Experiment Study on Selection Mechanism of Project Delivery Method Based on Complex Factors

Factors governing construction project delivery selection: A content analysis

Key factors affecting project delivery system selection in the Chinese construction industry

A NOVEL DECISION-MAKING MODEL FOR SELECTING A CONSTRUCTION PROJECT DELIVERY SYSTEM

Bidding Strategy to Support Decision-Making Based on Comprehensive Information in Construction Projects

Decision‐Making Evaluation and Optimization Strategies for Construction EPC Project Developers Utilizing BIM Technology

Delivering Complex Engineering Projects: Reexamining Organizational Control Theory

Influence Mechanisms of Factors on Project Management Capability

A Special Partial Least Squares (PLS) Path Decision Modeling for Bid Evaluation of Large Construction Projects

Research on the coordination mechanism of major industrial project engineering and construction multi-agents based on structural holes theory

Enhancing Design Management by Partnering in Delivery of International Epc Projects: Evidence from Chinese Construction Companies

Research on the Synergy Management Mechanism of the Project Contract Using Management Based on the Multi-Sided Matching Decision Method

Research on Optimization of Project Design Management Process Based on BIM

Bid Evaluation for Major Construction Projects Under Large-Scale Group Decision-Making Environment and Characterized Expertise Levels

An integrated machine learning approach for evaluating critical success factors influencing project portfolio management adoption in the construction industry

Factors affecting expert performance in bid evaluation: An integrated approach

Study on the project supervision system based on the principal-agent theory

Study on Factors Affecting the Progress of Engineering Projects under the EPC Model

Compound mechanism design of supplier selection based on multi-attribute auction and risk management of supply chain

Adaptability Analysis of Integrated Project Delivery Method in Large- and Medium-Sized Engineering Projects: A FAHP-Based Modeling Solution

A study on incentive mechanism of the large-scale construction performance audit based on the computational experiment