Abstract:The current large empirical literature on interest rate modeling typically focuses on the in-sample performance and ignores the out-of-sample performance of existing models. We fill the gap in this literature by providing probably the first comprehensive empirical study (to our knowledge) of the out-of-sample performance of a wide variety of popular interest rate models in forecasting the probability density of future interest rates. Out-of-sample density forecasts are important for at least two reasons: (i) out-of-sample analysis helps minimize the data snooping bias due to excessive searching for more complicated models using the same or similar data sets; (ii) the conditional probability density, which completely characterizes the dynamics of an interest rate model, is an essential input to many important financial applications such as pricing fixed-income securities and interest rate risk management. Using a rigorous econometric procedure developed in Hong (2000) for density forecast evaluation, we examine the out-of-sample performance of single-factor diffusion, GARCH, regime-switching and jump-diffusion models. Among other things we focus on the relative importance of (i) linear versus nonlinear drift specification in modeling conditional mean, (ii) level versus GARCH effect in modeling conditional variance, and (iii) regime-switching versus jumps in capturing the tail distribution of interest rate data. Consistent with the in-sample findings in the literature, we find that for out-of-sample density forecasts, it is important to model mean-reversion, conditional heteroskedasticity, and excess kurtosis or heavy-tails of interest rates. Contrary to the in-sample findings, we find that models that perform well in out-of-sample forecasts are those with simpler specifications for all the above three important features. Our results point out the potential risk of overparameterization in the existing interest rate models and show that simplicity is indeed a virtue in out-of-sample applications.

Modeling the Dynamics of Shanghai Interbank Offered Rate Based on Single-Factor Short Rate Processes

Modeling the dynamics of Chinese spot interest rates

Short-term Interest Rate Model Suitable to Shanghai Interbank Offered Rate

Performance of Discrete-Time Spot Rate Models in China: an Empirical Test on Chinese Repo Rates

Short rate dynamics with stochastic volatilities and jumps

Double Smoothed Volatility Estimation of Potentially Non‐stationary Jump‐diffusion Model of Shibor

Asymmetry of return distribution, abnormality of intradaily risk based on quantile regression model with high-frequency data from Shanghai stock market

Interest rate model with jump-mean reverting stochastic mean

Dynamic Research for Term Structure of Shibor

Maximum Pseudo-Likelihood Estimation of Interest Rate Models for China Interbank Offer Rate

Parametric and Nonparametric Analysis of the Short Interest Rate in Chinese Bond Market

Modeling on Interest Rate Behavior of RMB: Comparative Research Based on Vasicek, CIR and CKLS Model

An Empirical Comparison of the Dynamic Behavior of Short Interest Rate with Repo Rates in the Inter-bank Market and Shanghai Security Exchange Market of China Based on CKLS Model

Out-of-Sample Performance of Discrete-Time Spot Interest Rate Models

New Test of Asset Pricing Models in China

Uncertain Interest Rate Model for Shanghai Interbank Offered Rate and Pricing of American Swaption

Empirical Research on the Jump Behavior of Chinese Short Rate

Bayesian Testing for Short Term Interest Rate Models

An Empirical Analysis of Shanghai Stock Market in Using a Modified Functional Coefficient Autoregressive Model Method

Modeling Yield Curves in the SSE with Two-Factor Affine and Gaussian Essential Affine Models

Out-of-Sample Performance of Spot Interest Rate Models