When do stereotypes undermine indirect reciprocity?
Mari Kawakatsu,Sebastián Michel-Mata,Taylor A. Kessinger,Corina E. Tarnita,Joshua B. Plotkin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1011862
2024-03-02
PLoS Computational Biology
Abstract:Social reputations provide a powerful mechanism to stimulate human cooperation, but observing individual reputations can be cognitively costly. To ease this burden, people may rely on proxies such as stereotypes, or generalized reputations assigned to groups. Such stereotypes are less accurate than individual reputations, and so they could disrupt the positive feedback between altruistic behavior and social standing, undermining cooperation. How do stereotypes impact cooperation by indirect reciprocity? We develop a theoretical model of group-structured populations in which individuals are assigned either individual reputations based on their own actions or stereotyped reputations based on their groups' behavior. We find that using stereotypes can produce either more or less cooperation than using individual reputations, depending on how widely reputations are shared. Deleterious outcomes can arise when individuals adapt their propensity to stereotype. Stereotyping behavior can spread and can be difficult to displace, even when it compromises collective cooperation and even though it makes a population vulnerable to invasion by defectors. We discuss the implications of our results for the prevalence of stereotyping and for reputation-based cooperation in structured populations. Someone who behaves altruistically can gain a good social standing, which makes others more likely to help them in the future. This feedback between altruistic behavior and reputation, called indirect reciprocity, is a key mechanism for promoting cooperation in large societies. However, keeping track of each individual's social standing may be difficult. To reduce the mental burden, people sometimes rely on proxies, such as stereotypes based on group affiliations. But how do stereotypes affect reputation-based cooperation? We study this problem using a mathematical model in which individuals are judged either by their individual reputation, based on their own behavior, or by their stereotyped reputation, based on the behavior of their group. Using stereotypes can facilitate or impede cooperation, depending on how people share their views of one another. When individuals adjust their behavior through social learning, stereotype usage tends to spread, and it can persist at high levels even when it is detrimental to cooperation. This study helps us understand the spread of stereotyping behavior and its downstream impact on reputations and cooperation in populations with group structure.
biochemical research methods,mathematical & computational biology