Abstract:Segmentation is crucial in geographic object-based image analysis for accurate land use and land cover mapping. However, obtaining outstanding segmentation results in all scenarios proves challenging with a single algorithm. This study investigates seven segmentation algorithms: mean shift (MF), O Sistema de Processamento de informações georreferenciadas (the geographic information and image processing system) (SPRING), Estimation of scale parameter 2 (ESP2) (three global-scale algorithms), image object detection approach (IODA), SA, edge-guided image object detection approach (EIODA) (three local-scale optimization algorithms), and segment anything model (SAM) (deep learning). In the custom dataset and semantic segmentation datasets, we apply visual interpretation, unsupervised, and supervised evaluation methods with 15 test images, using a total of 17 evaluation indices to assess the segmentation results. Based on the evaluation results, the effectiveness and adaptability of the algorithms in scene segmentation are comprehensively analyzed. The results report that global-scale segmentation approaches encounter difficulties in distinguishing meaningful objects in complicated scenarios. Both MF and SPRING methods are prone to over-segmentation. In many cases, ESP2 tends to generate homogeneous segments (low weighted variance), whereas EIODA tends to produce heterogeneous adjacent segments (low Moran's I). ED3 and segmentation evaluation index demonstrate that scale parameter (SA) and IODA can to some extent identify geo-objects, with SA being more effective and performing exceptionally well in building extraction. The EIODA performs well in areas with clear boundaries, like aquaculture ponds and water-land transitions. SAM accurately detects objects of various sizes, displaying rich semantic content and high consistency with reference polygons. The average intersection over union reaches 71.10% and F measure attains 0.77 under normal conditions.

A Discrepancy Measure for Segmentation Evaluation from the Perspective of Object Recognition

Discrepancy measures for selecting optimal combination of parameter values in object-based image analysis

Accuracy Evaluation of Segmentation for High Resolution Imagery and 3D Laser Point Cloud Data

A Novel Quality Evaluating Method for Over-Segmentation Approaches Using Real-Time Boundary Information

Segmentation Quality Evaluation Using Region-Based Precision and Recall Measures for Remote Sensing Images

Accuracy Assessment Measures for Object-Based Image Segmentation Goodness

A Fast and Effective Method for Unsupervised Segmentation Evaluation of Remote Sensing Images

Objective Performance Evaluation of Video Segmentation Algorithms with Ground-Truth

Evaluation of Global-Scale and Local-Scale Optimized Segmentation Algorithms in GEOBIA With SAM on Land Use and Land Cover

A Novel Method for Assessing the Segmentation Quality of High-Spatial Resolution Remote-Sensing Images

Accuracy Evaluating Method for Object-Based Segmentation of High Resolution Remote Sensing Image

Objective Object Segmentation Visual Quality Evaluation Based on Pixel-Level and Region-Level Characteristics

Segmentation for Object-Based Image Analysis (OBIA): A review of algorithms and challenges from remote sensing perspective

Edge-Based Unsupervised Evaluation of Image Segmentation.

A survey on evaluation methods for image segmentation

Guidelines to Compare Semantic Segmentation Maps at Different Resolutions

Another Look on Region Merging Procedure from Seed Region Shift for High-Resolution Remote Sensing Image Segmentation

Toward Evaluating Multiscale Segmentations of High Spatial Resolution Remote Sensing Images

Objective Image Quality Measures and Their Applications in Segmentation Evaluation

New Evaluation Metrics for Mesh Segmentation

Double-Variance Measures: A Potential Approach to Parameter Optimization of Remote Sensing Image Segmentation