Abstract:Hydrological models play an important role in water resource management, but they always suffer from various sources of uncertainties. Therefore, it is necessary to implement uncertainty analysis to gain more confidence in numerical modeling. The study employed three methods (i.e., Parameter Solution (ParaSol), Sequential Uncertainty Fitting (SUFI2), and Generalized Likelihood Uncertainty Estimation (GLUE)) to quantify the parameter sensitivity and uncertainty of the SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) model in a mountain-loess transitional watershedJingchuan River Basin (JCRB) on the Loess Plateau, China. The model was calibrated and validated using monthly observed streamflow at the Jingchuan gaging station and the modeling results showed that SWAT performed well in the study period in the JCRB. The parameter sensitivity results demonstrated that any of the three methods were capable for the parameter sensitivity analysis in this area. Among the parameters, CN2, SOL_K, and ALPHA_BF were more sensitive to the simulation of peak flow, average flow, and low flow, respectively, compared to others (e.g., ESCO, CH_K2, and SOL_AWC) in this basin. Although the ParaSol method was more efficient in capturing the most optimal parameter set, it showed limited ability in uncertainty analysis due to the narrower 95CI and poor P-factor and R-factor in this area. In contrast, the 95CIs in SUFI2 and GLUE were wider than ParaSol, indicating that these two methods can be promising in analyzing the model parameter uncertainty. However, for the model prediction uncertainty within the same parameter range, SUFI2 was proven to be slightly more superior to GLUE. Overall, through the comparisons of the proposed evaluation criteria for uncertainty analysis (e.g., P-factor, R-factor, NSE, and R-2) and the computational efficiencies, SUFI2 can be a potentially efficient tool for the parameter optimization and uncertainty analysis. This study provides an insight into selecting uncertainty analysis method in the modeling field, especially for the hydrological modeling community.

Identification of Water Quality Model Parameter Based on Finite Difference and Monte Carlo

Water quality model parameter identification of an open channel in a long distance water transfer project based on finite difference, difference evolution and Monte Carlo.

Impact Of Two Calibration Strategies On Flow Simulation In Qiantang River Basin, China

Parameter Optimization of Hydrologic Model Parameters Based on Regional Sensitivity Analysis and SCEM-UA Algorithm

A Bayesian Approach for the Identification of Pollution Source in Water Quality Model Coupled with Hydrodynamics

Numerical Approach for Water Distribution System Model Calibration Through Incorporation of Multiple Stochastic Prior Distributions.

Markov Chain Monte Carlo scheme for parameter uncertainty analysis in water quality model]

Parameters Identification for Water Environmental System Based on Bayesian Inference

Source Identification of Sudden Contamination Based on the Parameter Uncertainty Analysis

[Parameters Identification and Uncertainty Analysis for Environmental Model].

The Parameters Optimization in Hydrogeological Model Based on MCMC Method

Bayesian framework of parameter sensitivity, uncertainty, and identifiability analysis in complex water quality models.

Assessment of Parameter Uncertainty for Non-Point Source Pollution Mechanism Modeling: A Bayesian-based Approach

Identification of pollution sources in rivers using a hydrodynamic diffusion wave model and improved Bayesian-Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm

The parameters estimation method based on Bayesian optimization for complex water quality models

Parameter Identification for Modeling River Network Using a Genetic Algorithm

Application of Genetic Algorithm and Simplex Method in Parameter Identification of Complicated Environmental Model

Parameter Uncertainty Analysis Of The Swat Model In A Mountain-Loess Transitional Watershed On The Chinese Loess Plateau

Parameter Identification of Complicated Environmental Model Using the Soft-computing Approach

Simultaneous Identification of Groundwater Contaminant Sources and Simulation of Model Parameters Based on an Improved Single-Component Adaptive Metropolis Algorithm

Comparison Between Two Calibration Methods for Water Quality Model Based on Uncertainty Analysis Technique