Reactor Performance and Economic Evaluation of Anaerobic Co-Digestion of Dairy Manure with Corn Stover and Tomato Residues under Liquid, Hemi-Solid, and Solid State Conditions
Yangyang Li,Fuqing Xu,Yu Li,Jiaxin Lu,Shuyan Li,Ajay Shah,Xuehua Zhang,Hongyu Zhang,Xiaoyan Gong,Guoxue Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biortech.2018.08.061
IF: 11.4
2018-01-01
Bioresource Technology
Abstract:Anaerobic co-digestion is commonly believed to be benefical for biogas production. However, additional of co-substrates may require additional energy inputs and thus affect the overall energy efficiency of the system. In this study, reactor performance and energy analysis of solid state anaerobic digestion (SS-AD) of tomato residues with dairy manure and corn stover were investigated. Different fractions of tomato residues (0, 20, 40, 60, 80 and 100%, based on volatile solid weight (VS)) were co-digested with dairy manure and corn stover at 15% total solids. Energy analysis based on experimental data was conducted for three scenarios: SS-AD of 100% dairy manure, SS-AD of binary mixture (60% dairy manure and 40% corn stover, VS based), and SS-AD of ternary mixture (36% dairy manure, 24% corn stover, and 40% tomato residues, VS based). For each scenario, the energy requirements for individual process components, including feedstock collection and transportation, feedstock pretreatment, biogas plant operation, digestate processing and handling, and the energy production were examined. Results showed that the addition of 20 and 40% tomato residues increased methane yield compared to that of the dairy manure and corn stover mixture, indicating that the co-digestion could balance nutrients and improve the performance of solid-state anaerobic digestion. The energy required for heating substrates had the dominant effect on the total energy consumption. The highest volatile solids (VS) reduction (57.0%), methane yield (379.1 WIT VSreed), and net energy production were achieved with the mixture of 24% corn stover, 36% dairy manure, and 40% tomato residues. Thus, the extra energy input for adding tomato residues for co-digestion could be compensated by the increase of methane yield. (C) 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.