Abstract:Recently we uploaded to the arxiv a paper entitled: Improving the Economic Complexity Index. There, we compared three metrics of the knowledge intensity of an economy, the original metric we published in 2009 (the Economic Complexity Index or ECI), a variation of the metric proposed in 2012, and a variation we called ECI+. It was brought to our attention that the definition of ECI+ was equivalent to the variation of the metric proposed in 2012. We have verified this claim, and found that while the equations are not exactly the same, they are similar enough to be our own oversight. More importantly, we now ask: how many variations of the original ECI work? In this paper we provide a simple unifying framework to explore multiple variations of ECI, including both the original 2009 ECI and the 2012 variation. We found that a large fraction of variations have a similar predictive power, indicating that the chance of finding a variation of ECI that works, after the seminal 2009 measure, are surprisingly high. In fact, more than 28 percent of these variations have a predictive power that is within 90 percent of the maximum for any variation. These findings show that, once the idea of measuring economic complexity was out, creating a variation with a similar predictive power (like the ones proposed in 2012) was trivial (a 1 in 3 shot). More importantly, the result show that using exports data to measure the knowledge intensity of an economy is a robust phenomenon that works for multiple functional forms. Moreover, the fact that multiple variations of the 2009 ECI perform close to the maximum, tells us that no variation of ECI will have a performance that is substantially better. This suggests that research efforts should focus on uncovering the mechanisms that contribute to the diffusion and accumulation of productive knowledge instead of on exploring small variations to existing measures.

The Knowledge Base of an Economy : What is it ? Can it be measured ? Can it be modeled ?

return Can the KnowledgeBase of an Economy Be Measured ? 1 *

Communication and Knowledge: How is the knowledge base of an economy constructed?

Measuring the Knowledge Base of an Economy in terms of Triple-Helix Relations among 'Technology, Organization, and Territory'

The Knowledge-Based Economy and the Triple Helix Model

How to Measure Knowledge Economy

National Systems of Innovation , the Triple Helix : Can the KnowledgeBase of an Economy be Measured ?

Knowledge Economics: A View of Evolution

Knowledge Production in a Cooperative Economy

Measuring the Knowledge Base: A Program of Innovation Studies

"Medium-tech" industries may be of greater importance to a local economy than "High-tech" firms: New methods for measuring the knowledge base of an economic system

The Knowledge-Based Economy: The Potentially Globalizing and Self-Organizing Dynamics of Interactions among Differently Codified Systems of Communication

"While a Storm is Raging on the Open Sea": Regional Development in a Knowledge-based Economy

The use of knowledge in open-ended systems

The Triple Helix of University-Industry-Government Relations (february 2012)

A Critical Review of the Precursors of the Knowledge Economy and Their Contemporary Research: Implications for the Computerized New Economy

Measuring the bioeconomy economically: exploring the connections between concepts, methods, data, indicators and their limitations

The triple helix model and the study of knowledge-based innovation systems

729 new measures of economic complexity (Addendum to Improving the Economic Complexity Index)

The Triple Helix, Quadruple Helix, . . ., and an N-tuple of Helices: Explanatory Models for Analyzing the Knowledge-based Economy?

Knowledge in the economic growth of developing economies