Abstract:Objectives: Experimental pain is a commonly used method to draw conclusions about the motor response to clinical musculoskeletal pain. A systematic review was performed to determine if current models of acute experimental pain validly replicate the clinical experience of appendicular musculoskeletal pain with respect to the distribution and quality of pain and the pain response to provocation testing. Methods: A structured search of Medline, Scopus and Embase databases was conducted from database inception to August 2020 using the following key terms: "experimental muscle pain" OR "experimental pain" OR "pain induced" OR "induced pain" OR "muscle hyperalgesia" OR ("Pain model" AND "muscle"). Studies in English were included if investigators induced experimental musculoskeletal pain into a limb (including the sacroiliac joint) in humans, and if they measured and reported the distribution of pain, quality of pain or response to a provocation manoeuvre performed passively or actively. Studies were excluded if they involved prolonged or delayed experimental pain, if temporomandibular, orofacial, lumbar, thoracic or cervical spine pain were investigated, if a full text of the study was not available or if they were systematic reviews. Two investigators independently screened each title and abstract and each full text paper to determine inclusion in the review. Disagreements were resolved by consensus with a third investigator. Results: Data from 57 experimental pain studies were included in this review. Forty-six of these studies reported pain distribution, 41 reported pain quality and six detailed the pain response to provocation testing. Hypertonic saline injection was the most common mechanism used to induce pain with 43 studies employing this method. The next most common methods were capsaicin injection (5 studies) and electrical stimulation, injection of acidic solution and ischaemia with three studies each. The distribution of experimental pain was similar to the area of pain reported in clinical appendicular musculoskeletal conditions. The quality of appendicular musculoskeletal pain was not replicated with the affective component of the McGill Pain Questionnaire consistently lower than that typically reported by musculoskeletal pain patients. The response to provocation testing was rarely investigated following experimental pain induction. Based on the limited available data, the increase in pain experienced in clinical populations during provocative maneuvers was not consistently replicated. Conclusions: Current acute experimental pain models replicate the distribution but not the quality of chronic clinical appendicular musculoskeletal pain. Limited evidence also indicates that experimentally induced acute pain does not consistently increase with tests known to provoke pain in patients with appendicular musculoskeletal pain. The results of this review question the validity of conclusions drawn from acute experimental pain studies regarding changes in muscle behaviour in response to pain in the clinical setting.

Acid-induced Experimental Muscle Pain and Hyperalgesia with Single and Repeated Infusion in Human Forearm.

Muscle Fatigue Increases the Probability of Developing Hyperalgesia in Mice

Effects of Intrathecal Morphine on Excitatory Amino Acid Contents of Spinal Cord in a Rat Model of Incision Pain

Acid evoked thermal hyperalgesia involves peripheral P2Y1 receptor mediated TRPV1 phosphorylation in a rodent model of thrombus induced ischemic pain

Effect of Intramuscular Protons, Lactate, and ATP on Muscle Hyperalgesia in Rats

Acid-sensing Ion Channels 3: a Potential Therapeutic Target for Pain Treatment in Arthritis.

Effects of acid-sensing ion channels 3 subunit in arthritis pain

Acute experimentally-induced pain replicates the distribution but not the quality or behaviour of clinical appendicular musculoskeletal pain. A systematic review

Homotopic and heterotopic variation in skin blood flow and temperature following experimental muscle pain in humans.

The related mechanism of complete Freund's adjuvant-induced chronic inflammation pain based on metabolomics analysis

Citric Acid in Drug Formulations Causes Pain by Potentiating Acid-Sensing Ion Channel 1

Acid-sensing ion channel 1a mediates acid-induced increases in intracellular calcium in rat articular chondrocytes

Acidosis-related pain and its receptors as targets for chronic pain

Molecular and Behavioral Changes in Nociception in a Novel Rat Model of Chronic Pancreatitis for the Study of Pain

Exogenously applied muscle metabolites synergistically evoke sensations of muscle fatigue and pain in human subjects

Regulatory T-cells and IL-5 mediate pain outcomes in a preclinical model of chronic muscle pain

Astrocyte activation in hindlimb somatosensory cortex contributes to electroacupuncture analgesia in acid-induced pain

Single Subcutaneous Injection of Lysophosphatidyl-Choline Evokes ASIC3-Dependent Increases of Spinal Dorsal Horn Neuron Activity

Experimentally induced pain and paresthesia respond differently to parameter changes of cuff-based compression in pain-free young individuals

Peripheral acid-sensing ion channels and P2X receptors contribute to mechanical allodynia in a rodent thrombus-induced ischemic pain model

Involvement of Inflammasome Activation Via Elevation of Uric Acid Level in Nociception in a Mouse Model of Muscle Pain.