Abstract:It is widely agreed upon that morality guides people with conflicting interests towards agreements of mutual benefit. We therefore might expect numerous proposals for organizing human moral cognition around the logic of bargaining, negotiation, and agreement. Yet, while "contractualist" ideas play an important role in moral philosophy, they are starkly underrepresented in the field of moral psychology. From a contractualist perspective, ideal moral judgments are those that would be agreed to by rational bargaining agents—an idea with wide-spread support in philosophy, psychology, economics, biology, and cultural evolution. As a practical matter, however, investing time and effort in negotiating every interpersonal interaction is unfeasible. Instead, we propose, people use abstractions and heuristics to efficiently identify mutually beneficial arrangements. We argue that many well-studied elements of our moral minds, such as reasoning about others' utilities ("consequentialist" reasoning) or evaluating intrinsic ethical properties of certain actions ("deontological" reasoning), can be naturally understood as resource-rational approximations of a contractualist ideal. Moreover, this view explains the flexibility of our moral minds—how our moral rules and standards get created, updated and overridden and how we deal with novel cases we have never seen before. Thus, the apparently fragmentary nature of our moral psychology—commonly described in terms of systems in conflict—can be largely unified around the principle of finding mutually beneficial agreements under resource constraint. Our resulting "triple theory" of moral cognition naturally integrates contractualist, consequentialist and deontological concerns.

On David Gauthier's Morals by Agreement

On the Union of Human's Morality and Happiness from a Perspective of Prisoners' Dilemma in the Game Theory

On Morality and Interests

Moral Positive Illusion: Self–other Valuation Difference in Moral Foundation Theory

Enjoyment Involved in the Ethic Issues

A mutualistic approach to morality: the evolution of fairness by partner choice

The Ethics of Self-respect and Mutual Respect: From the Mutual Disinterest of Rawls

Some Problems on the Distinction between Rightness and Profit

Between Knowledge and Virtue---On the Rational Pursuit of and Rebellion against Western Morality

On the Reciprocation of Morality

Prisoner' s Rights in the View of Contractualism

An Evaluation of the Ultimate Principle of Morality by Ideal Experiments

Discussion about Morals Behavior and Moral Character

Principles of Moral Accounting: How our Intuitive Moral Sense Balances Rights and Wrongs

On the Establishment of the Principle of Public Order and Good Morals

On Public Place and Social Morality

Moral preferences in bargaining

Resource-rational contractualism: A triple theory of moral cognition

On morality:a comparative analysis of two moralities

On Ten Issues on the Formal Rationality of Law

The Basic Theoretical Problems to Be Made Clear in the Public Morality