Impact of UK National Institute of Health and Care Excellent (NICE) Clinical Guidelines (CG 168) on the Referral and Management of Leg Ulcers

a h davies,m a popplewell,l kelly,g r bate,k a l darvall,a w bradbury

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvsv.2015.10.028

2016-01-01

Abstract:UK NICE Clinical Guidelines CG 168 published in July 2013 recommended that venous leg ulcers (defined as break in the skin below the knee that has not healed within 2 weeks) be referred for specialist vascular assessment. Aim: To determine the impact of NICE CG 168 on referrals to our leg ulcer clinic. This was a comparison of prospectively gathered data on patients referred to clinic before (January 2011 to June 2012) and after (January 2014 to June 2015) NICE CG 168. There was a twofold increase in referrals (181 patients, 220 legs vs 385 patients, 453 legs) but no change in mean age (75 years; range, 23-104 years), gender (45% men), duration of ulcer at referral (median, 16 weeks; range, 7-46 weeks), or at first clinic appointment (median, 20 [IQR 12-36] weeks vs 23 [IQR 12-52] weeks). Mean time from referral to clinic increased (4.8 vs 6 weeks; P = .0001), as did the proportion with superficial venous insufficiency (SVI; 35.5% vs 43.7% legs; P = .05). There was an increase in ulcers due solely to SVI that had been present for <6 months (15.0% vs 23.0% legs; P = .02). There was no change in deep venous disease (8.2% vs 8.8% legs) or pure arterial ulcers (9.5% vs 11.7% legs). but there was a significant reduction in arteriovenous ulcers (5.9% vs 1.3% legs; P = .0018) and also a significant reduction nonvascular ulceration (47.7% vs 34.4% legs; P = .0012). No patient underwent traditional venous surgery. There was a nonsignificant increase in ulcerated legs undergoing endovenous intervention (34.4% vs 43.2% legs; P = .271) but a significant increase in endothermal ablation (2 vs 32 legs; P = .001) with no change in ultrasound-guided foam sclerotherapy (24 vs 51 legs) or compression (62.8% vs 63% legs). There was a significant reduction in those treated conservatively with simple dressings (26% vs 15% legs; P = .0006). Since publication of NICE CG 168, there has been a doubling of patients referred with leg ulceration. However, many are still not being referred until they have had an ulcer for many months. Although many ulcers are multifactorial and the mainstay if treatment remains compression, there has been an increase in the use of endovenous intervention. Further efforts are required to persuade family doctors and community nurses to refer patients earlier for specialist vascular assessment as recommended by NICE CG 168.