Adapting The Joy Luck Club: Thematic Emphasis through Form

wanlin li

2010-01-01

Abstract:E): The paper investigates how the connection between mothers and daughters gains prominence through specific formal features in the film adaptation of The Joy Luck Club (1993). Narrative strategies (embedding and framing) and stylistic choices (size of shots, camera angle, camera movement and film music) are closely analyzed for their thematic function and significance. In the comparison between the novel and film, the essay revisits the historical argument revolving around fidelity. It provides further evidence for the inevitability of changes in the process of adaptation and urges formally oriented readings as a means to understand the relationship (particularly the difference) between literary and cinematic narrative. Abstract (F): Cet article met en valeur le theme des liens entre meres et filles a travers une analyse formelle de l'adaptation cinematographique de The Joy Luck Club (1993). Il se concentre surtout sur certaines strategies narratives (emboitement et cadrage) et certains choix stylistiques (nature des plans, choix des angles, mouvements de camera et musique). En comparant le roman et le film, l'article reinterroge aussi les debats traditionnels sur la fidelite. Il demontre avec force que toute adaptation implique necessairement des transformations et souligne la necessite de pratiquer une lecture formelle afin de mieux comprendre les rapports (mais surtout les differences) entre la narration litteraire et la narration cinematographique.