A universal transition to turbulence in channel flow

Masaki Sano,Keiichi Tamai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nphys3659

IF: 19.684

2016-01-01

Nature Physics

Abstract:Experiments and simulations of the transition to turbulence in fluid flow through a quasi-2D channel reveal critical exponents consistent with directed percolation — long conjectured to be the universality class associated with the transition.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Universal Critical Behavior at a Phase Transition to Quantum Turbulence

Masahiro Takahashi,Michikazu Kobayashi,Kazumasa A. Takeuchi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1609.01561

2016-09-06

Abstract:Turbulence is one of the most prototypical phenomena of systems driven out of equilibrium. While turbulence has been studied mainly with classical fluids like water, considerable attention is now drawn to quantum turbulence (QT), observed in quantum fluids such as superfluid helium and Bose-Einstein condensates. A distinct feature of QT is that it consists of quantum vortices, by which turbulent circulation is quantized. Yet, under strong forcing, characteristic properties of developed classical turbulence such as Kolmogorov's law have also been identified in QT. Here, we study the opposite limit of weak forcing, i.e., the onset of QT, numerically, and find another set of universal scaling laws known for classical non-equilibrium systems. Specifically, we show that the transition belongs to the directed percolation universality class, known to arise generically in transitions into an absorbing state, including transitions to classical shear-flow turbulence after very recent studies. We argue that quantum vortices play an important role in our finding.

Quantum Gases,Other Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics,Fluid Dynamics
Universality at the onset of turbulence in shear flows

Alberto de Lozar,Bjoern Hof

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1001.2481

2010-01-14

Abstract:The volatile transition from quiescent laminar to strongly fluctuating turbulent dynamics in shear flows remains only poorly understood despite its practical importance and more than a century of intense research. The theoretical understanding of the transition process has been complicated by the lack of a linear instability mechanism and additionally by a catastrophic collapse of turbulence which can occur after extremely long lifetimes. Turbulence close to onset is investigated experimentally in three different geometries: pipe, duct and channel flow. The reverse transition from turbulent to laminar flow is observed to be a general feature of shear flows. A critical point is uncovered at slightly higher flow rates, where the nature of the flow changes abruptly to the generic case of expanding turbulence. The critical exponent associated with this phase transition is found to be universal. This confirms a conjecture made over 20 years ago based on an analogy between fluid turbulence and discrete models in statistical physics.

Fluid Dynamics
Phase transition to turbulence via moving fronts

Sébastien Gomé,Aliénor Rivière,Laurette S. Tuckerman,Dwight Barkley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.264002

2024-07-02

Abstract:Directed percolation (DP), a universality class of continuous phase transitions, has recently been established as a possible route to turbulence in subcritical wall-bounded flows. In canonical straight pipe or planar flows, the transition occurs via discrete large-scale turbulent structures, known as puffs in pipe flow or bands in planar flows, which either self-replicate or laminarize. However, these processes might not be universal to all subcritical shear flows. Here, we design a numerical experiment that eliminates discrete structures in plane Couette flow and show that it follows a different, simpler transition scenario: turbulence proliferates via expanding fronts and decays via spontaneous creation of laminar zones. We map this phase transition onto a stochastic one-variable system. The level of turbulent fluctuations dictates whether moving-front transition is discontinuous, or continuous and within the DP universality class, with profound implications for other hydrodynamic systems.

Fluid Dynamics
The Unified Transition Stages in Linearly Stable Shear Flows

Jianjun Tao,Xiangming Xiong

2017-01-01

Abstract:Abrupt transition to turbulence may occur in pipe and channel flows at moderate flow rates, an unexpected event according to linear stability theory, and has been an open problem in fluid dynamics for more than a century. Extensive numerical simulations and statistical analyses of the plane-Poiseuille flow have been performed. A sequence of transition stages, which includes the equilibrium localized turbulence, the temporally persistent turbulence and the uniform turbulence, is identified. The spread of turbulent band is mainly caused by an oblique extension at moderate Reynolds numbers and band splitting at high Reynolds numbers. The small scale regime of a turbulent band coincides with the oblique swirl region of the mean flow in planes parallel to the walls. Furthermore, this transition scenario is shown quantitatively to be universal for channel and pipe flows in terms of a locally defined Reynolds number.
Statistical transition to turbulence in plane channel flow

Sébastien Gomé,Laurette S. Tuckerman,Dwight Barkley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.5.083905

2020-08-26

Abstract:Intermittent turbulent-laminar patterns characterize the transition to turbulence in pipe, plane Couette and plane channel flows. The time evolution of turbulent-laminar bands in plane channel flow is studied via direct numerical simulations using the parallel pseudospectral code ChannelFlow in a narrow computational domain tilted by $24^{\circ}$ with respect to the streamwise direction. Mutual interactions between bands are studied through their propagation velocities. Energy profiles show that the flow surrounding isolated turbulent bands returns to the laminar base flow over large distances. Depending on the Reynolds number, a turbulent band can either decay to laminar flow or split into two bands. As with past studies of other wall-bounded shear flows, in most cases survival probabilities are found to be consistent with exponential distributions for both decay and splitting, indicating that the processes are memoryless. Statistically estimated mean lifetimes for decay and splitting are plotted as a function of the Reynolds number and lead to the estimation of a critical Reynolds number $Re_{\text{cross}}\simeq 965$, where decay and splitting lifetimes cross at greater than $10^6$ advective time units. The processes of splitting and decay are also examined through analysis of their Fourier spectra. The dynamics of large-scale spectral components seem to statistically follow the same pathway during the splitting of a turbulent band and may be considered as precursors of splitting.

Fluid Dynamics
Directed percolation and puff jamming near the transition to pipe turbulence

Grégoire Lemoult,Vasudevan Mukund,Hong-Yan Shih,Gaute Linga,Joachim Mathiesen,Nigel Goldenfeld,Björn Hof

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41567-024-02513-0

IF: 19.684

2024-05-28

Nature Physics

Abstract:The onset of turbulence in pipe flow has defied detailed understanding ever since the first observations of the spatially heterogeneous nature of the transition. Recent theoretical studies and experiments in simpler, shear-driven flows suggest that the onset of turbulence is a directed-percolation non-equilibrium phase transition, but whether these findings are generic and also apply to open or pressure-driven flows is unknown. In pipe flow, the extremely long time scales near the transition make direct observations of critical behaviour virtually impossible. Here we find a technical solution to that limitation and show that the universality class of the transition is directed percolation, from which a jammed phase of puffs emerges above the critical point. Our method is to experimentally characterize all pairwise interactions between localized patches of turbulence puffs and use these interactions as input for renormalization group and computer simulations of minimal models that extrapolate to long length and time scales. The strong interactions in the jamming regime enable us to explicitly measure the turbulent fraction and confirm model predictions. Our work shows that directed-percolation scaling applies beyond simple closed shear flows and underscores how statistical mechanics can lead to profound, quantitative and predictive insights on turbulent flows and their phases.

physics, multidisciplinary
Directed Percolation Criticality in Turbulent Liquid Crystals.

Kazumasa A. Takeuchi,Masafumi Kuroda,Hugues Chate,Masaki Sano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.99.234503

IF: 8.6

2007-01-01

Physical Review Letters

Abstract:We experimentally investigate the critical behavior of a phase transition between two topologically different turbulent states of electrohydrodynamic convection in nematic liquid crystals. The statistical properties of the observed spatiotemporal intermittency regimes are carefully determined, yielding a complete set of static critical exponents in full agreement with those defining the directed percolation class in 2+1 dimensions. This constitutes the first clear and comprehensive experimental evidence of an absorbing phase transition in this prominent nonequilibrium universality class.
Influence of turbulent mixing on critical behavior of directed percolation process: Effect of compressibility

J Honkonen,T Lučivjanský,V Škultéty

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.97.022123

Abstract:Universal behavior is a typical emergent feature of critical systems. A paramount model of the nonequilibrium critical behavior is the directed bond percolation process that exhibits an active-to-absorbing state phase transition in the vicinity of a percolation threshold. Fluctuations of the ambient environment might affect or destroy the universality properties completely. In this work, we assume that the random environment can be described by means of compressible velocity fluctuations. Using field-theoretic models and renormalization group methods, we investigate large-scale and long-time behavior. Altogether, 11 universality classes are found, out of which 4 are stable in the infrared limit and thus macroscopically accessible. In contrast to the model without velocity fluctuations, a possible candidate for a realistic three-dimensional case, a regime with relevant short-range noise, is identified. Depending on the dimensionality of space and the structure of the turbulent flow, we calculate critical exponents of the directed percolation process. In the limit of the purely transversal random force, critical exponents comply with the incompressible results obtained by previous authors. We have found intriguing nonuniversal behavior related to the mutual effect of compressibility and advection.
Size-dependent transient nature of localized turbulence in transitional channel flow

Dong Xü,Baofang Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2209.15184

2022-01-01

Abstract:It has been reported that a fully localized turbulent band in channel flow becomes sustained when the Reynolds number is above a threshold. Here we show evidences that turbulent bands are of a transient nature instead. When the band length is controlled to be fixed, lifetimes of turbulent bands appear to be stochastic and exponentially distributed, a sign of a memoryless transient nature. Besides increasing with the Reynolds number, the mean lifetime also strongly increases with the band length. Given that the band length always changes over time in real channel flow, this size dependence may translate into a time dependence, which needs to be taken into account when clarifying the relationship between channel flow transition and the directed percolation universality class.
Size-dependent Transient Nature of Localized Turbulence in Transitional Channel Flow

Duo Xu,Baofang Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2022.839

IF: 3.7

2022-01-01

Journal of Fluid Mechanics

Abstract:It has been reported that a fully localized turbulent band in channel flow becomes sustained when the Reynolds number is above a threshold. Here we show evidence that turbulent bands are of a transient nature instead. When the band length is controlled to be fixed, the lifetime of turbulent bands appears to be stochastic and exponentially distributed, a sign of a memoryless transient nature. Besides increasing with the Reynolds number, the mean lifetime also strongly increases with the band length. Given that the band length always changes over time in real channel flow, this size dependence may translate into a time dependence, which needs to be taken into account when clarifying the relationship between channel flow transition and the directed percolation universality class.
Experimental Realization Of Directed Percolation Criticality In Turbulent Liquid Crystals

Kazumasa A. Takeuchi,Masafumi Kuroda,Hugues Chaté,Masaki Sano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.80.051116

IF: 2.707

2009-01-01

Physical Review E

Abstract:This is a comprehensive report on the phase transition between two turbulent states of electroconvection in nematic liquid crystals, which was recently found by the authors to be in the directed percolation (DP) universality class [K. A. Takeuchi , Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 234503 (2007)]. We further investigate both static and dynamic critical behaviors of this phase transition, measuring a total of 12 critical exponents, 5 scaling functions, and 8 scaling relations, all in full agreement with those characterizing the DP class in 2+1 dimensions. Developing an experimental technique to create a seed of topological-defect turbulence by pulse laser, we confirm in particular the rapidity symmetry, which is a basic but nontrivial consequence of the field-theoretic approach to DP. This provides a clear experimental realization of this outstanding truly out-of-equilibrium universality class, dominating most phase transitions into an absorbing state.
Extended Localized Structures and the Onset of Turbulence in Channel Flow

J. J. Tao,Bruno Eckhardt,X. M. Xiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevfluids.3.011902

IF: 2.895

2018-01-01

Physical Review Fluids

Abstract:In this letter, it is shown numerically that in plane Poiseuille flow and before the threshold of equilibrium turbulence defined by the directed-percolation universality class, a sparse turbulent state in form of localized turbulent band can sustain either by continuous increase of the turbulence fraction due to band extension when the flow domain is large enough, or by a dynamic balance between the band extension and the band breaking and decay caused by the band interaction in a finite domain. The width and tilt angle of the band keep statistically invariant during its oblique extension, a process which is not sensitive to random disturbances.
How to experimentally probe universal features of absorbing phase transitions using steady state

Keiichi Tamai,Masaki Sano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/aaeb42

2018-10-23

Abstract:We propose experimentally feasible ways to probe universal features of absorbing phase transitions from two different approaches, both based on numerical validations. On one hand, we numerically study a probability distribution of duration/length of intervals of local inactive state in quasi-steady state, which has been very commonly used in experiments, in a case of the contact process. We show that the distributions obey the universal scaling ansatz expected from phenomenological scaling argument, but that care must be taken in order to suppress a bias caused by censoring due to a finite observation window. To demonstrate the latter point, we compare the distributions for the temporal intervals estimated through conventional histograms with those through the estimator which properly takes account of censoring and sampling bias. On the other hand, we also propose that, if a system is subject to uniform advection as is often the case with flowing systems, a correlation length and a correlation time near the transition point can be easily quantified by supplying the system with an active boundary condition. In order to support our proposal, we introduce a new model whose advection strength can be arbitrarily controlled. The results of numerical simulations on our model suggest that a correlation time, which is difficult to measure through the interval distributions without the aforementioned bias, can be measured through characteristic decay length of an order parameter. Crossovers between two different power-law behaviors are also identified in this case, and the universal scaling ansätze associated with the crossovers are discussed.

Physics
Transitions of Power-Law Fluids in Two-Dimensional Lid-Driven Cavity Flow Using Lattice Boltzmann Method

Zhang Heng,Ren Feng,Hu Hai-Bao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.7498/aps.70.20210451

IF: 0.906

2021-01-01

Acta Physica Sinica

Abstract:Studying transitions from laminar to turbulence of non-Newtonian fluids can provide a theoretical basis to further mediate their dynamic properties. Compared with Newtonian fluids, transitions of non-Newtonian fluids turning are less focused, thus being lack of good predictions of the critical Reynolds number (Re) corresponding to the first Hopf bifurcation. In this study, we employ the lattice Boltzmann method as the core solver to simulate two-dimensional lid-driven flows of a typical non-Newtonian fluid modeled by the power rheology law. Results show that the critical Re of shear-thinning (5496) and shear-thickening fluids (11546) are distinct from that of Newtonian fluids (7835). Moreover, when Re is slightly larger than the critical one, temporal variations of velocity components at the monitor point all show a periodic trend. Before transition of the flow filed, the velocity components show a horizontal straight line, and after transition, the velocity components fluctuate greatly and irregularly. Through fast Fourier transform for the velocity components, it is noted that the velocity has a dominant frequency and a harmonic frequency when Re is marginally larger than the critical one. Besides, the velocity is steady before transition of flow filed, so it appears as a point on the frequency spectrum. As the flow filed turns to be turbulent, the frequency spectrum of the velocity component appears multispectral. Different from a single point in the velocity phase diagram before transition, the velocity phase diagram after transition forms a smooth and closed curve, whose area is also increasing as Re increases. The center point of the curve moves along a certain direction, while movement directions of different center points are different. Proper orthogonal decompositions for the velocity and vorticity field reveal that the first two modes, in all types of fluids, are the dominant modes when Re is close to the critical one, with energy, occupying more than 95% the whole energy. In addition, for one type of fluid, the dominant modes at different Re values have similar structures. Results of the first and second modes of velocity field show that the modal peak is mainly distributed in vicinity of the cavity wall.
Universal threshold of the transition to localized turbulence in shear flows

jianjun tao,shiyi chen,weidong su

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/2.1105202

2011-01-01

Theoretical and Applied Mechanics Letters

Abstract:Experimental and numerical studies have shown similarities between localized turbulence in channel and pipe flows. By scaling analysis of a disturbed-flow model, this paper proposes a local Reynolds number ReM to characterize the threshold of transition triggered by finite-amplitude disturbances. The ReM represents the maximum contribution of the basic flow to the momentum ratio between the nonlinear convection and the viscous diffusion. The lower critical ReM observed in experiments of plane Poiseuille flow, pipe Poiseuille flow and plane Couette flow are all close to 323, indicating the uniformity of mechanism governing the transition to localized turbulence.
Discontinuous transition to shear flow turbulence

Yi Zhuang,Bowen Yang,Vasudevan Mukund,Elena Marensi,Björn Hof

2023-11-20

Abstract:Depending on the type of flow the transition to turbulence can take one of two forms, either turbulence arises from a sequence of instabilities, or from the spatial proliferation of transiently chaotic domains, a process analogous to directed percolation. Both scenarios are inherently continuous and hence the transformation from ordered laminar to fully turbulent fluid motion is only accomplished gradually with flow speed. Here we show that these established transition types do not account for the more general setting of shear flows subject to body forces. By attenuating spatial coupling and energy transfer, spatio-temporal intermittency is suppressed and with forcing amplitude the transition becomes increasingly sharp and eventually discontinuous. We argue that the suppression of the continuous range and the approach towards a first order, discontinuous scenario applies to a wide range of situations where in addition to shear, flows are subject to e.g. gravitational, centrifugal or electromagnetic forces.

Fluid Dynamics
A thermodynamic study of the two-dimensional pressure-driven channel flow

Weinan E,Jianchun Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3934/dcds.2016.36.4349

2016-01-01

Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems

Abstract:The instability of the two-dimensional Poiseuille flow in a long channel and the subsequent transition using thermodynamic approach. The idea is to view the transition process as an initial value problem with the initial condition being Poiseuille flow plus noise, which is considered as our ensemble. Using the mean energy of the velocity fluctuation and the skin friction coefficient as the macrostate variable, we analyze the transition process triggered by the initial noises with different amplitudes. A first order transition is observed at the critical Reynolds number Re. 5772 in the limit of zero noise. An action function, which relates the mean energy with the noise amplitude, is defined and computed. The action function depends only on the Reynolds number, and represents the cost, for the noise to trigger a transition from the laminar flow. The correlation function of the spatial structure is analyzed.
Flow Through Porous Media at the Percolation Transition

Mirko Residori,Suvendu Mandal,Axel Voigt,Christina Kurzthaler

2024-05-21

Abstract:We study low-Reynolds-number fluid flow through a two-dimensional porous medium modeled as a Lorentz gas. Using extensive finite element simulations we fully resolve the flow fields for packing fractions approaching the percolation threshold. Near the percolation transition, we find a power-law scaling of the flow rate versus the pressure drop with an exponent of $\approx 5/2$, which has been predicted earlier by mapping the macroscopic flow to a discrete flow network [Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 1985]. Importantly, we observe a rounding of the scaling behavior at small system sizes, which can be rationalized via a finite-size scaling ansatz. Finally, we show that the distribution of the kinetic energy exhibits a power-law scaling over several decades at small energies, originating from collections of self-similar, viscous eddies in the dead-end-channels. Our results lay the foundation for unraveling critical behavior of complex fluids omnipresent in biological and geophysical systems.

Fluid Dynamics,Soft Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics
Deterministic and Stochastic Aspects of the Transition to Turbulence

Baofang Song,Bjoern Hof

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/2014/02/p02001

2014-01-01

Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment

Abstract:The purpose of this contribution is to summarize and discuss recent advances regarding the onset of turbulence in shear flows. The absence of a clear-cut instability mechanism, the spatio-temporal intermittent character and extremely long lived transients are some of the major difficulties encountered in these flows and have hindered progress towards understanding the transition process. We will show for the case of pipe flow that concepts from nonlinear dynamics and statistical physics can help to explain the onset of turbulence. In particular, the turbulent structures (puffs) observed close to onset are spatially localized chaotic transients and their lifetimes increase super-exponentially with Reynolds number. At the same time fluctuations of individual turbulent puffs can (although very rarely) lead to the nucleation of new puffs. The competition between these two stochastic processes gives rise to a non-equilibrium phase transition where turbulence changes from a super-transient to a sustained state.
Upper edge of chaos and the energetics of transition in pipe flow

Nazmi Burak Budanur,Elena Marensi,Ashley P. Willis,Björn Hof

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevFluids.5.023903

2019-12-19

Abstract:In the past two decades, our understanding of the transition to turbulence in shear flows with linearly stable laminar solutions has greatly improved. Regarding the susceptibility of the laminar flow, two concepts have been particularly useful: the edge states and the minimal seeds. In this nonlinear picture of the transition, the basin boundary of turbulence is set by the edge state's stable manifold and this manifold comes closest in energy to the laminar equilibrium at the minimal seed. We begin this paper by presenting numerical experiments in which three-dimensional perturbations are too energetic to trigger turbulence in pipe flow but they do lead to turbulence when their amplitude is reduced. We show that this seemingly counter-intuitive observation is in fact consistent with the fully nonlinear description of the transition mediated by the edge state. In order to understand the physical mechanisms behind this process, we measure the turbulent kinetic energy production and dissipation rates as a function of the radial coordinate. Our main observation is that the transition to turbulence relies on the energy amplification away from the wall, as opposed to the turbulence itself, whose energy is predominantly produced near the wall. This observation is further supported by the similar analyses on the minimal seeds and the edge states. Furthermore, we show that the time-evolution of production-over-dissipation curves provide a clear distinction between the different initial amplification stages of the transition to turbulence from the minimal seed.

Fluid Dynamics,Chaotic Dynamics

A universal transition to turbulence in channel flow

Universal Critical Behavior at a Phase Transition to Quantum Turbulence

Universality at the onset of turbulence in shear flows

Phase transition to turbulence via moving fronts

The Unified Transition Stages in Linearly Stable Shear Flows

Statistical transition to turbulence in plane channel flow

Directed percolation and puff jamming near the transition to pipe turbulence

Directed Percolation Criticality in Turbulent Liquid Crystals.

Influence of turbulent mixing on critical behavior of directed percolation process: Effect of compressibility

Size-dependent transient nature of localized turbulence in transitional channel flow

Size-dependent Transient Nature of Localized Turbulence in Transitional Channel Flow

Experimental Realization Of Directed Percolation Criticality In Turbulent Liquid Crystals

Extended Localized Structures and the Onset of Turbulence in Channel Flow

How to experimentally probe universal features of absorbing phase transitions using steady state

Transitions of Power-Law Fluids in Two-Dimensional Lid-Driven Cavity Flow Using Lattice Boltzmann Method

Universal threshold of the transition to localized turbulence in shear flows

Discontinuous transition to shear flow turbulence

A thermodynamic study of the two-dimensional pressure-driven channel flow

Flow Through Porous Media at the Percolation Transition

Deterministic and Stochastic Aspects of the Transition to Turbulence

Upper edge of chaos and the energetics of transition in pipe flow