Abstract:Transparency of information disclosure has always been considered an instrumental component of effective governance, accountability, and ethical behavior in any organization or system. However, a natural question follows: \emph{what is the cost or benefit of being transparent}, as one may suspect that transparency imposes additional constraints on the information structure, decreasing the maneuverability of the information provider. This work proposes and quantitatively investigates the \emph{price of transparency} (PoT) in strategic information disclosure by comparing the perfect Bayesian equilibrium payoffs under two representative information structures: overt persuasion and covert signaling models. PoT is defined as the ratio between the payoff outcomes in covert and overt interactions. As the main contribution, this work develops a bilevel-bilinear programming approach, called $Z$-programming, to solve for non-degenerate perfect Bayesian equilibria of dynamic incomplete information games with finite states and actions. Using $Z$-programming, we show that it is always in the information provider's interest to choose the transparent information structure, as $0\leq \textrm{PoT}\leq 1$. The upper bound is attainable for any strictly Bayesian-posterior competitive games, of which zero-sum games are a particular case. For continuous games, the PoT, still upper-bounded by $1$, can be arbitrarily close to $0$, indicating the tightness of the lower bound. This tight lower bound suggests that the lack of transparency can result in significant loss for the provider. We corroborate our findings using quadratic games and numerical examples.

Clarity Vs. Publicity in Disclosure of Public Information

Selective Disclosure of Public Information: Who Needs to Know?

Disclosure in insurance law: a comparative analysis

Optimal and Robust Disclosure of Public Information

Information Relevance, Reliability, and Disclosure

Information disclosure quality: correlation versus precision

Government Information Disclosure and the Expansion of Public Reason

Which is Better, Selective Disclosure or Fair Disclosure? the Effects of Information Asymmetry and Incentive Misalignment

Information Disclosure and Consumer Awareness

On the Price of Transparency: A Comparison between Overt Persuasion and Covert Signaling

Investor Attention and Disclosure Effectiveness

The Diminishing Publicity of Public Policy:Risk Analysis and Governance

Strategic disclosure with reputational concerns

Information disclosure and price discovery

Does Public Disclosure Crowd out Private Information Production?

On the Optimality of Full Disclosure

The Role of Asymmetric Disclosure When Price Efficiency Affects Real Efficiency

Endogenous Information Acquisition and Disclosure of Private Information in a Duopoly

Public disclosure with information sharing in financial market

Optimal Design of Climate Disclosure Policies: Transparency versus Externality

The Dynamic Effect of Public Information on Liquidity: From the Perspective of Limited Attention