Abstract:The Chinese government has been working hard to improve environmental performance. However, considering that public feedback is not always complimentary, there is still room for improvement in its protection work. In China, environmental planning is the dominant direction of the government’s environmental governance. Therefore, an analysis of environmental planning could explain the policy incentives that lead to inconsistent performance and satisfaction, and could enable us to explore how to improve planning to more effectively achieve environmental governance goals. This study classified 37 Chinese cities into four types based on consistency in performance and satisfaction. Taking environmental planning policy as the research object, the planning work arrangements of different cities to improve environmental performance and public satisfaction were analyzed through hand-coding. Our study found that environmental planning in these cities puts more emphasis on basic and engineering arrangements that can effectively improve environmental performance, while work arrangements that involve improving public environmental satisfaction are relatively few. Moreover, (1) cities with high environmental performance and high public satisfaction have made relatively substantial arrangements in improving environmental performance and satisfaction during environmental planning; (2) cities with high environmental performance and low public satisfaction have a certain foundation for environmental governance, but tough governance or high public expectations weaken environmental satisfaction; (3) cities with low environmental performance and high public environmental satisfaction have low environmental performance values due to the huge energy consumption of resources or a lack of pollution disposal capacity; and (4) most of the cities with low environmental performance and low public environmental satisfaction share common geographical and historical environmental problems that make it challenging to considerably enhance public satisfaction and environmental performance in the short term. Based on the above findings, this paper believes that greater environmental governance can be achieved by promoting a change in environmental planning from the existing “elite” planning paradigm to a “participatory” planning model.

Improving Government Accountability in the Face of Environmental Challenges

Government Responsibilities for Public Participation in China's Environmental Protection——Based On Environmental Information Disclosure Responsibilities

Reform of China's Environmental Regulatory System: from Sector-Based Management to Public Management

Government's Environmental Responsibility and the Modification of the Environmental Protection Law

China's Environment on a Metacoupled Planet

Between Disclosure and Nondisclosure: Conflicts and Balance Between the Right to Environmental Information and Government Authority to Manage the Environmental Information

Discussion of "Environmental Governance Equity"

How Does Government Information Service Quality Influence Public Environmental Awareness?

Information, Incentives, and Environmental Governance: Evidence from China's Ambient Air Quality Standards

Strengthen the government's environmental responsibility——a view of the modification of the environmental protection law

Reforming China's multi-level environmental governance: Lessons from the 11th Five-Year Plan

Changes in China's Environment Policy Since Reform and Opening Up

Transparency and information disclosure in China's environmental governance

Government Responsiveness and Citizen Satisfaction: Evidence from Environmental Governance

Does the change of official promotion assessment standards contribute to the improvement of urban environmental quality?

How does the environmental attention of local governments affect regional green development? Empirical evidence from local governments in China

Challenges of water environment governance in China: based on a qualitative comparative analysis approach

Consistency Between Environmental Performance and Public Satisfaction and Their Planning Intervention Strategies: A Policy Text Analysis of Urban Environmental Planning

Corporate environmental disclosure and local government environmental oversight in China

Governance Approach to China's Environmental Challenges: Towards a Theoretical Synthesis

Environmental Justice in China:Problems and Solutions