Abstract:Chromatin immunoprecipitation coupled to next-generation sequencing (ChIP-seq) has served as the central method for the study of histone modifications for the past decade. In ChIP-seq analyses, antibodies selectively capture nucleosomes bearing a modification of interest and the associated DNA is then mapped to the genome to determine the distribution of the mark. This approach has several important drawbacks: (i) ChIP interpretation necessitates the assumption of perfect antibody specificity, despite growing evidence that this is often not the case. (ii) Common methods for evaluating antibody specificity in other formats have little or no bearing on specificity within a ChIP experiment. (iii) Uncalibrated ChIP is reported as relative enrichment, which is biologically meaningless outside the experimental reference frame defined by a discrete immunoprecipitation (IP), thus preventing facile comparison across experimental conditions or modifications. (iv) Differential library amplification and loading onto next-generation sequencers, as well as computational normalization, can further compromise quantitative relationships that may exist between samples. Consequently, the researcher is presented with a series of potential pitfalls and is blind to nearly all of them. Here we provide a detailed protocol for internally calibrated ChIP (ICeChIP), a method we recently developed to resolve these problems by spike-in of defined nucleosomal standards within a ChIP procedure. This protocol is optimized for specificity and quantitative power, allowing for measurement of antibody specificity and absolute measurement of histone modification density (HMD) at genomic loci on a biologically meaningful scale enabling unambiguous comparisons. We provide guidance on optimal conditions for next-generation sequencing (NGS) and instructions for data analysis. This protocol takes between 17 and 18 h, excluding time for sequencing or bioinformatic analysis. The ICeChIP procedure enables accurate measurement of histone post-translational modifications (PTMs) genome-wide in mammalian cells as well as Drosophila melanogaster and Caenorhabditis elegans, indicating suitability for use in eukaryotic cells more broadly.

Quantitative Comparison of ChIP-Seq Data Sets Using MAnorm

MAnorm: a Robust Model for Quantitative Comparison of ChIP-Seq Data Sets

MAnorm2 for Quantitatively Comparing Groups of ChIP-seq Samples

Comparative ChIP-seq (Comp-ChIP-seq): a practical guideline for experimental design and a novel computational methodology

Computer and Statistical Analysis of Transcription Factor Binding and Chromatin Modifications by ChIP-seq Data in Embryonic Stem Cell

QChIPat: a quantitative method to identify distinct binding patterns for two biological ChIP-seq samples in different experimental conditions

Diffreps: Detecting Differential Chromatin Modification Sites from ChIP-seq Data with Biological Replicates.

A Practical Guide for DNase-seq Data Analysis: from Data Management to Common Applications

Normalization and experimental design for ChIP-chip data

ChIP-chip versus ChIP-seq: Lessons for experimental design and data analysis

Evaluation of ChIC-based data requires normalization that properly retains signal-to-noise ratios

A novel method for the normalization of ChIP-qPCR data

Native internally calibrated chromatin immunoprecipitation for quantitative studies of histone post-translational modifications

Highly quantitative measurement of differential protein-genome binding with PerCell chromatin sequencing

Summary of ChIP-Seq Methods and Description of an Optimized ChIP-Seq Protocol

An Integrated Software System for Analyzing ChIP-chip and ChIP-seq Data

Mapping of Transcription Factor Binding Regions in Mammalian Cells by ChIP: Comparison of Array- and Sequencing-Based Technologies

Integrative Analysis of Histone ChIP‐seq and RNA‐seq Data

Copy number normalization distinguishes differential signals driven by copy number differences in ATAC-seq and ChIP-seq

DiffChIPL: a differential peak analysis method for high-throughput sequencing data with biological replicates based on limma

ChIPbinner: An R package for analyzing broad histone marks binned in uniform windows from ChIP-Seq or CUT&RUN/TAG data