Abstract:Dealing with missing data is an important problem in statistical analysis that is often addressed with imputation procedures. The performance and validity of such methods are of great importance for their application in empirical studies. While the prevailing method of Multiple Imputation by Chained Equations (MICE) with Predictive Mean Matching (PMM) is considered standard in the social science literature, the increase in complex datasets may require more advanced approaches based on machine learning. In particular, tree-based imputation methods have emerged as very competitive approaches. However, the performance and validity are not completely understood, particularly compared to the standard MICE PMM. This is especially true for inference in linear models. In this study, we investigate the impact of various imputation methods on coefficient estimation, Type I error, and power, to gain insights that can help empirical researchers deal with missingness more effectively. We explore MICE PMM alongside different tree-based methods, such as MICE with Random Forest (RF), Chained Random Forests with and without PMM (missRanger), and Extreme Gradient Boosting (MIXGBoost), conducting a realistic simulation study using the German National Educational Panel Study (NEPS) as the original data source. Our results reveal that Random Forest-based imputations, especially MICE RF and missRanger with PMM, consistently perform better in most scenarios. Standard MICE PMM shows partially increased bias and overly conservative test decisions, particularly with non-true zero coefficients. Our results thus underscore the potential advantages of tree-based imputation methods, albeit with a caveat that all methods perform worse with an increased missingness, particularly missRanger.

Multiple Imputation with Multivariate Imputation by Chained Equation (mice) Package

Multiple Imputation for Time Series Data with Amelia Package

Multiple Imputation with Diagnostics ( Mi ) in R : Opening Windows into the Black Box

Multiple Imputation of Missing Categorical and Continuous Values via Bayesian Mixture Models with Local Dependence

Solving the "many variables" problem in MICE with principal component regression

Imputing Missing Data by Fully Conditional Models : Some Cautionary Examples and Guidelines

Multiple Imputation Through XGBoost

Supervised dimensionality reduction for multiple imputation by chained equations

A stacked approach for chained equations multiple imputation incorporating the substantive model

Adapting tree-based multiple imputation methods for multi-level data? A simulation study

MIMCA: Multiple imputation for categorical variables with multiple correspondence analysis

Missing Data Imputation: Focusing on Single Imputation.

What Is a Good Imputation Under MAR Missingness?

Multiple Imputation by Ordered Monotone Blocks with Application to the Anthrax Vaccine Research Program

Missing Data Exploration: Highlighting Graphical Presentation of Missing Pattern.

Multiple imputation for missing data: fully conditional specification versus multivariate normal imputation

Multiple imputation for longitudinal data: A tutorial

A Comparative Study of Imputation Methods for Multivariate Ordinal Data

Population-calibrated multiple imputation for a binary/categorical covariate in categorical regression models

Evaluating tree-based imputation methods as an alternative to MICE PMM for drawing inference in empirical studies

Multiple Imputation with Neural Network Gaussian Process for High-dimensional Incomplete Data