Abstract:It is an important step in deign under uncertainty to select an appropriate uncertainty propagation (UP) method considering the characteristics of the engineering systems at hand, the required level of UP associated with the probabilistic design scenario, and the required accuracy and efficiency levels. Many uncertainty propagation methods have been developed in various fields, however, there is a lack of good understanding of their relative merits. In this paper, a comparative study on the performances of several UP methods, including a few recent methods that have received growing attention, is performed. The full factorial numerical integration (FFNI), the univariate dimension reduction method (UDR), and the polynomial chaos expansion (PCE) are implemented and applied to several test problems with different settings of the performance nonlinearity, distribution types of input random variables, and the magnitude of input uncertainty. The performances of those methods are compared in moment estimation, tail probability calculation, and the probability density function (PDF) construction. It is found that the FFNI with the moment matching quadrature rule shows good accuracy but the computational cost becomes prohibitive as the number of input random variables increases. The accuracy and efficiency of the UDR method for moment estimations appear to be superior when there is no significant interaction effect in the performance function. Both FFNI and UDR are very robust against the non-normality of input variables. The PCE is implemented in combination with FFNI for coefficients estimation. The PCE method is shown to be a useful approach when a complete PDF description is desired. Inverse Rosenblatt transformation is used to treat non-normal inputs of PCE, however, it is shown that the transformation may result in the degradation of accuracy of PCE. It is also shown that in black-box type of system the performance and convergence of PCE highly depend on the method adopted to estimate its coefficients.

A Comparative Study of Uncertainty Propagation Methods for Black-Box Type Functions

Sensitivity Analysis of Random and Interval Uncertain Variables Based on Polynomial Chaos Expansion Method

Unified Reliability Measure Method Considering Uncertainties of Input Variables and Their Distribution Parameters

Uncertainty Quantification Using Polynomial Chaos Expansion with Points of Monomial Cubature Rules

An efficient uncertainty propagation method for nonlinear dynamics with distribution-free P-box processes

Uncertainty propagation method for high-dimensional black-box problems via Bayesian deep neural network

A collaborative quasi-Monte Carlo uncertainty propagation analysis method for multiple types of epistemic uncertainty quantified by probability boxes

Propagation algorithm for hybrid uncertainty parameters based on polynomial chaos expansion

Bayesian probabilistic propagation of hybrid uncertainties: Estimation of response expectation function, its variable importance and bounds

Enhanced Gaussian-mixture-model-based nonlinear probabilistic uncertainty propagation using Gaussian splitting approach

Derivative-Enhanced Rational Polynomial Chaos for Uncertainty Quantification

A Generalized Multi-Fidelity Simulation Method Using Sparse Polynomial Chaos Expansion

A new uncertainty propagation method considering multimodal probability density functions

Propagation of Input Uncertainty in Presence of Model-Form Uncertainty: A Multi-fidelity Approach for CFD Applications

UNCERTAINTY ANALYSIS METHOD BASED ON A COMBINATION OF THE MAXIMUM ENTROPY PRINCIPLE AND THE POINT ESTIMATION METHOD

A Comparative Study of Polynomial Chaos Expansion-Based Methods for Global Sensitivity Analysis in Power System Uncertainty Control

An efficient uncertainty propagation analysis method of non-parameterized P-boxes based on dimension-reduction integral and maximum entropy estimation

Modern Monte Carlo methods for efficient uncertainty quantification and propagation: A survey

Refined dimension-reduction integration method for uncertainty propagation in stochastic systems: estimation of statistical moments

Unified Uncertainty Analysis By The Extension Universal Generating Functions

An Efficient Bayesian Uncertainty Quantification Approach with Application to K-Ω-γ Transition Modeling