Chemo-radiotherapy Versus Radiotherapy Alone for Nasopharyngeal Carcinoma: A Meta-Analysis of 78 Randomized Controlled Trials (rcts) from English and Non-English Databases

K Thephamongkhol,J Zhou,G Browman,RKW Wong,JCK Chan,Y Zeng,L Thabane,I Hodson,T Oliver
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1200/jco.2004.22.14_suppl.5522
IF: 45.3
2004-01-01
Journal of Clinical Oncology
Abstract:5522 Background: To obtain the best estimate for survival benefits of chemo-radiotherapy (CT + RT) compared with radiotherapy alone (RT) in nasopharyngeal cancer (NPC) and to evaluate the optimal timing of CT Methods: Datasources: 10 English language databases, 6 Chinese, including hand searching 26 Chinese Oncology Journals, 3 Korean, 2 Japanese, 1 African and 1 South East Asian databases. The Cochrane search strategy was used. Study Selection: Published reports or abstracts of RCTs comparing CT + RT versus RT for newly diagnosed NPC. Data Extraction: 2 reviewers independently extracted data and scored for trial quality.Where available, authors were contacted for actual number of events. Quality Scores: 2 points for randomization, 1 for completeness of follow up and 1 for intention-to-treat analysis (score range 0–4) Results: Data Synthesis: 101 RCTs were identified, 88 from Chinese and 13 from English language. 78 RCTs (9279 pts) reported 2 year or longer survival with characteristics as follows: median quality score 2, median sample size 89, number of RCTs : neoadjuvant (N) only 28, concurrent (C) only 19, adjuvant (A) only 8, C+A 3, N+C 5, N+A 14, N+C+A 6 ( > 2 arms in 3 RCTs). CT was cisplatin in 68, non-cisplatin in 10. Pooled Analysis: [table] Across all trials, CT + RT improve overall survival (OS) and disease free survival (DFS). Concurrent CT with or without adjuvant CT and neoadjuvant CT alone all improve OS and DFS. Sensitivity analysis of 3 year OS was done by excluding poor quality studies. The results were unchanged; however the effect of all trials and of neoadjuvant CT are borderline when all Chinese trials were excluded. Conclusions: CT administered concurrently with or without adjuvant therapy + RT improves OS and DFS in NPC. The role of CT as neoadjuvant remains controversial when Chinese trials are excluded from the analysis. No significant financial relationships to disclose.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?